This is not the most likely scenario. It is not
at all likely that Nvidia has done nothing wrong.
----
My guesses… this is all hypotheticals but I think it is likely:
- Alice Huang will turn out to be an intelligence asset.
- Either way she is surely a smuggler, there are notable questions about her background, and Jensen Huang knew.
- Jensen Huang is an idiot who could actually be at some risk of going to prison because of the risks to national security inherent in his behaviour, particularly if he was advised about it.
- Tim Teter (Nvidia general counsel) is potentially in serious trouble too.
- Howard Lutnick and Jeff Kessler are possibly in an Oliver North type situation; Bessent and Rubio will hang them out to dry and have been covering themselves since they found out.
- Much more than just Megaspeed is implicated here — perhaps it will turn out that a quarter of the Asia Pacific sales of GPUs subsequently end up in mainland China or in the hands of wholly Chinese-controlled companies and more are leased by Chinese firms. (I am guessing at the size of this problem but I think it is a real problem for the export rules)
- Trump knew and did nothing.
- More evidence of Nvidia manipulating the GPU market will fall out of these inquiries.
----
Now, I am a non-American who only uses open weights local LLMs (though purely coincidentally I don't currently use any Chinese ones), so I don't really care about the export rules or about "Singapore-washing", and I don't care if the Chinese get GPUs, really. I personally care more about whether Nvidia's sales practices are inflating a bubble that will do global economic damage.
But I do think that what we are looking at here is potentially one of the biggest scandals in US industrial history. It absolutely could rival Iran-Contra in its long term impacts.
It doesn't really matter much if you are rich and important and think laws are stupid or wrong, if you broke them and there's someone there to enforce them.