1) Open Java Control Panel, see it says I have an update. Click "OK".
2) Reopen Java Control Panel because OK closes the window. This time click "Update Now"
3) After downloading 50MB another installer opens. Notice that it says 7u10 and not 7u11 (I was running 7u9).
4) Look back at Java Control Panel and see that it claims "Java Update was last run at 5:03 PM".
5) Reopen the JCP several times to try to force it to recognize that 7u11 is the latest, not 7u10.
6) Give up and install 7u10
7) Reopen JCP yet again. Success, 7u11 is available!
8) Click "Update Now" (not falling for your tricks again "OK" button)
10) Curse and post this.