School makes eBay mistake, sells $60K trailer for $1
tgdaily.com
tgdaily.com
$1 might be the true market value of the trailer right now. Maybe the buyer was doing the school a favor by taking it off their hands and saving them additional transportation costs.
I sold a junk car to a junkyard for $20 one time and was happy with the deal. I wasn't set up to sell the car's parts but the junkyard was. I got rid of the car, and the junkyard probably did pretty well selling the parts.
The article says that auction "enabled something like the BuyItNow feature with a $1 bid", which is a terrible way to describe not including a reserve price. The auction ran its course and BuyItNow never came into the picture.
My first impression when I saw the article was that the school got ripped off, and so if I had the chance, I would not have bought it.
The buyer might have thought that he was ripping off the school. So if he still wanted to rip off the school he could do a few things.
1. Sue the school in small claims court for cash. By the time the case has gotten to court it has probably been at least a month. And it looks like transporting those are really expensive. So it might be reasonable to argue that the buyer can't profitably move it and sell it at that time and so deserves cash.
2. Argue that he would have been able to get around the limit for small claims court lawsuits because the most expensive are going for over 24k, so 8k to 10k in damages might be reasonable.
So basically if the school didn't sell, they could be sued in small claims court which means a quick and inexpensive court case. And they might pay out more money than they would have gotten selling it.
Ebay:http://shop.ebay.com/items/__modular-office-trailer
PA small claims court: http://www.consumeraffairs.com/consumerism/small_pa.html
I have trouble believing this. It reminds me of Leonard v. Pepsico, Inc. Pepsi won, partly because "no reasonable person could have believed that the company seriously intended to convey a jet worth roughly $23 million for under a million dollars." [ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leonard_v._Pepsico,_Inc. ]
I don't know much about contract law, but there must be a way out of this.
It looks like it comes down to whether a "reasonable person" would be able to see that a mistake was made, and whether the buyer was intentionally taking advantage of what they should have known to be a mistake.
This is my favorite part. Instead of educating themselves and conducting the remaining auctions correctly, they're going to abandon the technology that would let them sell the trailers for market value and reach a wider audience.
Most likely, they'll now post them in a local classified ad for a price no one wants to pay ... then they'll sit and uglify the campus for 9+ months. A year or two later, they will end up paying to have them removed and discarded.
I worked at a college ... seen this stuff happen.
Furthermore, as posted in another comment, it's likely that the buyer didn't suspect anything -- similar to how freecycling is huge on Craigslist -- it's worth me giving it to you for basically free if it means you haul it away.
Until I see different, I wouldn't be casting aspersions on the character of the buyer so much as I would on the intelligence of the lister.
As I recall, you set a maximum bid and an incremental bid, and ebay automatically outbids other people for you until your maximum bid was reached.
He could've set a maximum bid of $60k, but, when no one else bid, wound up winning at the starting bid- which was set by the district at $1.