Of course, once you get to a certain level you can prove all the bits of science you want to prove and you can challenge a religious person to prove the validity their teaching (and see how far you get) but by then I'd imagine the individual has made up their mind one way or the other on religion.
I'd put more credence in the "the penalties for speaking out are much lower" suggestion.
And more to the point, while I only have a general knowledge of physics, I can Google "how do we know atoms exist" and get a pretty convincing answer, and I can search for good arguments saying atoms don't exist and come up empty. None of this is first-hand proof, of course - but it would be pretty compelling evidence. Can the same be said for theism?
Atheism isn't a religion. There is no "wrong reason" to be an atheist. If a guy on the street concludes there is no god, whether he got there by reading a textbook or personal whimsy has no bearing on my own absence of belief. It doesn't matter.