Hacker News Reader

Comment by sachinag | Hacker News Reader

10/10/40. I got bad advice. Everything's overbuilt because our guy, even though he's a member of the IVCA, didn't have standard docs.

View on HN

If $24k for IP is bad advice, what do you think the right number would have been?

Yokum (one of the absolute best out there) quotes $5K as a barebones starter package. I'm sure he'd have helped us avoid overbuilding on the IP in addition to the overbuilding on the corporate stuff.

http://www.startupcompanylawyer.com/faqs/

I refuse to believe you could get half as good as Yokum for twice the price.

He wouldn't remember it, but Yokum spent a good chunk of time on the phone with me and my cofounders when we started Matasano, as a favor for a mutual friend. I totally agree with you.

Having said that, I guess I was weaseling my way around to the point that a boilerplate IP agreement would cost next to nothing, and would probably be all you'd ever need. People obsess too much about IP, and not enough about their own execution risk.

(I know it's uncool to say here, but we're applying for a patent on our transaction engine. Even in the patent process, we probably could have saved some cash.)

Uncool isn't the word I'd use. I've got patent applications from 7+ years ago, with reputable IP lawyers working for going concerns, that are still "pending". My snipe at you might be "pointlessness". ;)

(but I can see why you spent so much money on IP now; patents are expensive).

Chicago investors kept telling me they would only invest in a company with "protectable IP." Coming from a healthcare VC background, I didn't question it. That was a mistake.

It is what it is at this point - so much money sunk into it that I want to finish it off.

The alternative approach to this is trade secrets law --- we've advised trading firms (for instance) that go through some formality to demonstrate controls on trade secret information for exactly this reason. But you'd probably have been screwed on lawyers either way.

Best of luck with the project.

Of course I remember you and Dave. We should separately catch up. Wondering what you did with the LLC and the other "founders."

Thank you for the kind words. Made my day.

He's saying 10k for inc., 10k for options, 40k for IP

Just to try & help clarify

Reply on news.ycombinator.com