Keep in mind this exchange took place in 2007, soon after the very first iPhone was launched.
Apple aren't exactly renowned for giving people a say in development, save a few royal elite. If your an untouchable at Apple, but are offered a good role at Palm, why not take it?
It's the old sentiment of would you rather live in a decrepid shack on a fancy road, or a grand house on a normal one.
If it is so absurd that someone would leave Apple for Palm, then why did they care and threaten so much?
I've always found it unethical. It's similar to going to a girl who has a boyfriend and saying "hey baby, I know you're dating Mike, but I would be such a better boyfriend for you..." Whether or not you would actually be a better boyfriend, or whether it is good for the girl, is quite besides the point.
Neither does your girlfriend. You are not an indentured servant to her. But the fact that you are dating her means that there is mutual trust on both sides, similar to that in an employee-employer arrangement. Poaching undermines that trust.
edit: not sure why I'm getting downvoted. "Don't downvote simply because you disagree" was an unspoken rule, I thought? If you have a disagreement, voice it.
Employer-employee relationships are asymmetrical and purely business oriented. There is no "trust" on their side, I can guarantee you that - that is why they have you sign NDA's when you work on secret things (I have yet to find a company that just trusts you to keep it all secret). That is why it is so beneficial for them to rely on you believing in precisely these sorts of analogies: they have lawyers and contracts on their side, you are left with believing in "loyalty" and "trust".
The fact that you equate contractual work between a corporation and a person to a loving relationship between two equals is quite demonstrative of my original point.
You don't have to pay your girlfriend to be with you, since presumably she also gets various benefits from dating you. Whether the transaction happens via money or some other medium such as care and attention is quite irrelevant.
I find it unbelievable that you are claiming there is no trust in employer-employee relationships. On the contrary, if you examine the basis of such relationships you'll find that the employer is giving you a job in the first place because they trust that you will be able to do it, and you are taking the job in the first place because you trust them that they won't screw you over.
Also, to address some other things you said previously:
>>You didn't sign a contract saying you'd work there for life.
I also didn't sign a contract I would date my girlfriend indefinitely. Note that I said girlfriend, not wife.
>>And more importantly, they will certainly fire you as soon as they need to.
Same thing with relationships: one person will break up with or divorce the other as soon as they feel like they aren't getting what they want or need out of the relationship.
>>This is in no way analogous to a committed marital relationship, where the entire idea is lifetime exclusivity, or dating when you are theoretically working towards that.
Again, I never said marriage. I said trying to poach a girl who is in a relationship (not marriage) is unethical, just like trying to poach another company's employee. If said employee comes seeking you out, then fine. But actively recruiting them because they work for Company X is huge bullshit, and I am saddened that so many intelligent people here try to justify it by claiming it is somehow good for the employee.
1. I brought up marriage (again, in my last comment), only to tie it to dating as an often expected outcome. In other words "these things apply to marriage, and since dating is usually used as a vehicle towards marriage, they thus apply to some degree to dating".
2. The reason dating is different is because there is an actual expectation of love, exclusivity, and longevity. There is absolutely no contract involved, thus these become the primary axis of the relationship. For example, note that if it is explicitly an open relationship, then the particular expectation of exclusivity disappears, in which case these actions would be legitimately considered "less scummy". With employment, there is a contract, and the other factors that you believe are influential to the relationship exist solely in your mind, and I will re-iterate, are in no way reciprocated by your employer. You will receive a bad surprise someday when you find out that the employer has no such notions of loyalty to you.
Finally, I am now really curious about your mindset. You seem incredibly insistent that employer-employee relationships are A LOT like dating. You believe that another company trying to hire you is like someone trying to steal a girlfriend. It only follows that you looking for other employment would be analogous to going on OKCupid behind her back? Is this how you feel as well? Do you think that employees should only try to find jobs after officially quitting and thus suffer possible windows of unemployment? Or is that the arbitrary point where the analogy ends in your mind?
This is a very important point. I've seen lots of people who have worked for years at a company laid off with no notice. One day they come into work and hear: "Pack your personal stuff in this box, hand over your company ID, and your manager will escort you out of the building."
Two relationship partners have roughly equal power, or failing that at least not a 100x or more disparity. This makes it a terrible analogy. The whole point of labour laws is to address this disparity.
no, it's not. there is not an unlimited supply of good and experiences people on the market. if you wan't to succeed you have to get them, somehow. it's competing for ressources, it's a good thing. it's frowned upon only if somebody good is "poached away", but not if you convince somebody from the competition to work for you.
FTFY. Labor is a market exactly like any other. If I buy Chevrolet for years and then suddenly switch to Ford because they offer a better deal was I "poached"? Such a nonsensical concept.
If you don't want people "poaching" your talent, pay them better. If you can't afford to then that's just the market efficiently allocating resources.
The competitor can try non-complete clauses, but those may not hold up legally. They can threaten to sue former employees who betray secrets, but it's pretty hard not to use or at least be inspired by what you've learned in a past job.
I don't see a good solution to this, but I can see why one would be upset by such "poaching."
That said, "do what we want or we'll sue you for patent infringement" is an inexcusable tactic.
This is covered by NDAs and if you can prove these were violated you can get something done about it. I've seen this happen.
>The competitor can try non-complete clauses, but those may not hold up legally.
I should certainly hope they wouldn't be held up legally. It's bullshit. The worker has a chance to make twice as much money. They shouldn't get blocked because some company thinks we're still in slavery times.
If it really matters so much to the company, they could just pay those workers double themselves (since, by definition, that's the market rate of those workers now). Moving is always a bit of a pain so if they're not already very unhappy they might even take less than double just to not have to move.
>They can threaten to sue former employees who betray secrets
If they can prove the NDA was violated they will sue and they will win.
>but it's pretty hard not to use or at least be inspired by what you've learned in a past job.
What you learn on the job is yours. This is known and completely accepted. If this were not the case then a Senior programmer would make the same money as a fresh-out-of-college Junior programmer.
You may find this extreme but some of us believe a programmer should get some kind of residuals for anything they write for a company the way authors/musicians/movie stars/sports players do for their work.
Talk to any senior manager and you will see their attitude manifest. The problem really is we are still largely ingrained in the feudal mindset. Employment is treated as a favor done by the company to the employee, and by that virtue employee is bound to life long slavery to the company. Hike, promotions are all treated as gracious favors from the company to the employee.
It's more like Ford figures out who owns a Chevrolet, and contacts them saying "psst, don't you hate your Chevy? Why don't you buy a Ford instead, we're so much better!" I don't know about you, but I find that sort of thing very creepy and unethical.
But this is a derail. The point remains, 'poaching' is a misnomer. It's offering competitive wages and communicating your desire to buy skilled labor at a higher rate than your competitors. It's a virtuous thing to do all around, and it's criminal to conspire against the workforce in order to profit at their expense.
If I'm remembering right, Palm basically had a standing offer to double the salary of anyone who worked on the iPhone at that point in time. That looked pretty attractive to some people.