#4 is wrong because the meritocracy has decided that Unity isn't good enough and it's failing
#7 is wrong because Ubuntu is trying to innovate on the desktop with Unity
and #8 is wrong because the fact that Unity exists and Ubuntu isn't shipping GNOME.
Really, #8 is very weak. User polls may favor Debian based distributions, but I'd expect that if you went by install base RPM is winning thanks to all the RHEL servers out there. Git is more popular than SVN because it's demonstrably better for many use cases, but we also have Hg. LibreOffice is the only real office suite out there, Google Docs is not quite the same thing.
#8 then goes to point out that we do have KDE vs. GNOME, which as the face of the desktop is a BIG difference. It also points out the hot competition between Chromium and Firefox, web browsers being one of the most used apps on any computer.
Listing 5 different Debian based distros and deciding that's a monoculture seems odd on it's face.
>Overall, the numbers fall short of a monopoly
To say that when "the numbers" in question are close to 50% is an understatement to say the least.