If you're making over $150k, then you're in the top 5% of households in the US by income.
If you're making over 100k, then you're in the top 10% of households in the US by income.
http://elsa.berkeley.edu/~saez/saez-UStopincomes-2006prel.pd...
There are some lines. I'd draw it at "top 5% by income."
I live in Denver, and within walking distance of my apartment I see homes ranging from $175k to $15M.
Should we subsidize the lifestyle to which you'd like to become accustomed - because you want to live in a nice area? I don't think so.
Likewise if you're a multimillionaire video-store owner who has a bad year and only makes $40K you're poor, and deserve some money from the mechanic?
What ever happened to the idea of treating each voter the same as every other voter? It seems to me like any kind of segmenting -- by income, by net worth, by religion, by race, by looks, etc -- starts to pit groups of people against each other.
I don't think there are lines, or rather I think drawing them is a really bad idea.
I think a better question is why shouldn't 'the rich' be paying a bigger portion of tax? You mention, 'minority group', but if you change that to 'the rich' (for a good definition of the word), the answer becomes imo that the rich can afford to pay more tax if they stop spending so much money. Many more people can live very with surprisingly less than what 'rich' people have. The answer should be to suck it up and deal with it.
Do they receive more of the benefit from their tax dollars? Probably not. National defense protects just about all citizens equally, public schools are hit and miss with tax dollars per student (which may be irrelevant because of private schooling for those who can afford it), and public services like libraries, roads, and protection are not distributed according to who pays more (except when you have higher income communities). If anything the rich receive less benefit per dollar taxed from them than any other group.
Now I'm all for helping out those in need, and giving those who don't earn as much a tax break, but in terms of justice and equality I think our tax system unfairly burdens the rich. But hey, they can handle it, right?
Therefore: whatever amount of taxation revenue you want to raise, and ignoring second-order effects (e.g., that higher tax rates reduce the incentive to work and increase the incentive to find ways to avoid/evade taxes) you will reduce the amount of harm done by collecting the taxes if you take more from the better-off and less from the worse-off.
Of course, once the differences between rates become very large, those "second-order" effects may no longer be small. If you ignore them entirely, I think the conclusion is that for maximum total utility you should tax + redistribute until everyone is equally well off, but long before you get there the "second-order" effects will be much more important.
Also, tax + redistribute until everyone is equal will never happen, even if there are no second-order effects, simply because people are different. Some are content to work x amount for $y, while others want to innovate, work harder, and do more.
The government should make the game equal, not the players.
Taxing the rich (for whatever definition of "rich") more doesn't mean believing that all rich people can easily afford to pay the extra, any more than not taxing the rich more means believing that all not-rich people can easily afford to pay the higher taxes they'll have to pay if the rich aren't taxed more. It just means believing that overall the population is better off that way.
(And yes, of course, tax+redistribute until equality is never actually going to happen, and a good thing too.)