Too Few Astronauts Have Died
toph.me
toph.me
However we are running - increasingly rapidly - into significant barriers of resource depletion. This is compounded by the fact that resource depletion itself can interfere with the capacity if society to solve big challenges.
Therefore if we don't get focused on getting a sustainable space presence now we may find we never do, having squandered our one time bounty of resources and society having peaked on its ability to deliver on grand programs.
It is an argument I have a lot of sympathy with. There are utopians out there who mistake technology for energy and believe smarts will necessarily overcome the coming energy crunch and its allied problems of resource depletion and overpopulation, as well as the relevant but slightly tangential issue if global climate change. I am not convinced.
That doesn't mean simple efficiency of using resources - doing more with the same or less - shouldn't be on the agenda. On the contrary, this is the primary way of staying ahead of the game. But let's not panic and get into "our golden age has passed, we're all screwed now". We're not and we did not offend our Mother Nature and it has not doomed us to eternal Hell of resourcelessness. We just need to keep being smart and inventive and work hard at using available resources with maximal efficiency.
Look at the population crunch arguments - saved by the Green Revolution right? Well that was just pouring fossil fuels on fields... we've burned through a lot of those and topsoil since. The sustainable carrying capacity of the planet is nothing like 7 billion by most sensible studies I've seen.
95% of the world's food production is dependent on fossil fuel inputs. As we pass peak flow - and we are clearly at peak oil flow rates right now (I feel confident saying as someone who worked in the oil industry and studies this stuff) pressures on those inputs will rise.
We used to mine 70% ores we now mine 5% ores of many key metals. We can do this, it's just more energy intensive. But eventually we've used all of the easy to access natural state resources and we are in a very different world.
Smarts don't replace atoms. Nor do they replace joules.
Most of the alternatives that folks have in the backs of their minds as "don't worry we have X" are net energy return on energy investment negative.
Then don't get me started on NPK inputs - cast an eye over Potash or Phosphate stocks recently? Nope most people haven't. But there's a reason the Russians are using their oil wealth to corner the market there.
Just because we have overcome serious problems before doesn't mean we always must. After the Great Depression we had vast stores of oil and most of these resources were barely touched. We don't have that get-out-of-jail-free card again. Just more mouths to feed and a world where climate change is increasing conflict and dislocation of populations.
Economic growth which gives us confidence in buying our way out of problems (which is a very utopian view given that you cannee change the laws of Physics as a great Scotsman once said) is not a given either. For all the economic theories out there, none have been tested in sustained periods of declining resource availability. Indeed nothing correlates more closely with economic growth than energy resource access - it's almost one to one if you plot them together over the centuries. So it's highly likely there's a causal relationship there that will have negative consequences as we slide down the other side of the energy resource curve.
Again, platitudes and proof are very different things. So far I've seen "sensible studies", and I can't see how they are different from the equally "sensible studies" in 70s that predicted worldwide resource exhaustion and mass hunger by 2000s.
>>>> After the Great Depression we had vast stores of oil and most of these resources were barely touched
We still have vast stores of oil and other hydrocarbons, many of which aren't even touched for ecological/political reasons. And there are also biotechnologies that allow conversion of solar energy, which are not very economically viable now, but if we start running out of stored hydrocarbons - can serve as one of the replacements. Of course, Sun will go out too sometime, but let's not worry about it just yet.
>>>> So it's highly likely there's a causal relationship there that will have negative consequences as we slide down the other side of the energy resource curve.
That's like saying since winning the lottery positively correlates with income increase, the only way to have sustainable income is to play a lot of lottery, and if one gets rid of lotteries, economic collapse is sure to follow. Of course having tons of oil is useful to whatever little petro-monarchies that have it. But it does not make Venezuela world's most advanced country and it does not make countries which do not have it less advanced.
Space exploration is significantly more long-term. You're spending billions of dollars (not just lives) for what in the short-term does not seem like much benefit. Although landing on the moon and other such projects are incredible achievements, and although the development of the technologies that have allowed such achievements has dramatically impacted daily life, it's much harder to make clear to people the benefits of exploration in both a human or a economic cost.
If the benefit is defeating Nazi Germany, or Assad's Syria, or Osama Bin Laden, we're able to accept the costs. If the benefit is Tupperware, GPS, and some cool pictures of the lunar surface, then we will most likely not (not that I agree with that, it's just how most people see it).
As a people and a nation we have paid a price to learn
That in any exploration, there are some who don't return.
We are neither fools nor cowards, to be shaken now to know
What our founders could have told us, twice a hundred years ago.
-- Echo's Children, "Columbia"The excited group of engineers when MSL touched down last year is testament to the fact that this landing is still very hard. (And the difficulty is not entirely due to not having a pilot in the craft.)
> But how much harder will it be to spare the resources when our cities are sinking, crops dying, population stagnating? It is cheaper now than it will ever again be. Debt, healthcare, war — these problems won’t be solved, leaving us free to tackle space, any time soon. They’ll probably get worse. And the best thing we can do for the Earth is get off of it.
An objective look at the data shows that the global state of human society is better now than it has ever been in history. There is no evidence that human civilization is at its peak.
Faking a sense of urgency is not a sustainable way to make the case for space exploration.