They should list placebo ingredients after the trial is done so it's possible to duplicate the trial and get the same results, right?
If you don't provide enough information in your paper to repeat the experiment (and get the same results!!), then it's not good science. Good scientific studies need to be repeatable and need to provide enough information to do it.
And even if people don't want to repeat the full experiment, being able to review the details of how it was done will help them spot mistakes. You can't have things like "peer review" without saying what you did.
So this is a serious problem, even if the rest is breathless hype.