Double your userbase with two lines of code and a box of Modafinil
alexkrupp.typepad.com
alexkrupp.typepad.com
We actually came up with what we call an "engagement" curve, which is the PERCENTAGE of people that will contribute at least X+1 times given they've contributed X times to the site.
Thanks!
So we can segment that out with various tests to see how it affects the engagement curve. For example, how does the curve shift when a user gets a personalized message? or a generic e-mail? Or does contribution type A, etc etc.
(though i guess if you could answer that correctly, maybe you could make it go away)
The solution: make it as fun as Call of Duty or Counter-Strike.
Problem: How do you make a website as fun as killing virtual terrorists? ... outside of having a website that let's you kill virtual terrorists.
Somwhere, someone gets a facebook developer account and and opens up vim.
You can make pretty much anything game-like: http://startup2startup.com/2009/01/09/jan29-amyjokim-shuffle...
Also, for questions which have been posted, I email the author (if they've given us their email address) and ask them if they're satisfied with the answer. If not, we'll spend some more time researching it and contact some special authority.
We've done that for one week, but the results have been mixed. I still think it's critical, but it's only one factor - you need the initial userbase just to get the new users to post.
EDIT: It also occurred to me (thinking about to pg's "If you measure it you'll improve it" quote") that I'll need some substantial reporting as well. To that end, I'll be writing some rake tasks today so I can plot the data over time.
You are discounting a very important factor - authority. Your co-founder is an authority figure, he's selling a site. He belongs in another group as the signed-up user. Another user sending a message is a peer. He tells the user that there are other people there, and that they are interested in what he is doing.
There is a big social difference in the two. Don't do one and never test the other.