Samsung: Solid state will match hard drive price
news.cnet.com
news.cnet.com
PS: I am assuming blue ray disks will cost around 10c per disk in 20 years. So flash needs to drop to 1/10,000th of it's current price to be competitive in that time scale.
I think within a few years most people will end up with a small (a few hundred GB) SSD for their OS and programs, and a very large traditional HD (a few TB) for archiving data that doesn't need random access.
That's the system I'm using now. Two 73GB 15K drives in Raid-1 for my OS, with 3 1TB drives in Raid-z for media.
I'm quite fascinated by all the ways we'll be able to persist data.
Right now a terabyte hard drive costs $81, and a terabyte of SSD costs $2684, I'm not going to hold my breath.
But by then, as you imply, the demanded capacity also will have increased...
So it seems to be a question of the rate differential. So far, SSD's are getting cheaper at a much faster rate than demanded capacities are increasing, and (assuming nothing changes the rates, like Blu-ray-sized 400GB movie downloads), it will catch up soon. Firstly just nipping at the heels of the low end, then biting a chunk out of the mainstream, and eventually consuming all but niche applications.
It has already caught up for lower capacities e.g., a 1 GB flash drive is cheaper than a 1 GB HDD (fixed costs: $2 vs $40-50), and disrupted hard drives from iPods and netbooks.
Meanwhile, desktops PCs themselves are being disrupted by laptops, which are being disrupted by netbooks.
However, I've already been looking into the SDD vs HDD and I'm swaying towards the HDD. I've already seen multiple USB flash failures, thankfully none were carrying data I didn't have backed up, however in a couple of situations we've got lucky; my wife's 8gb flash drive decided to fail when she needed it for college, so I had to load the back-up of her entire disk onto my FTP.
The USB flash cost $20 for 8gb, which was an introductory price as it's now $30 again. It had a 6 month warranty and failed a little bit past that line, the other one she got at the same time is running fine so I'm not going to call it as purposeful failures, but good warranty placing. However, for 4 times the price we paid, AKA $80, I've seen 160 gig 2.5" HDD with a warranty of 5 fucking years! Assuming flash drive sizes double every year for a similar base price of $20 then it's going to take at least 4 1/2 years for SSD to match the HDD and I'd have complete warranty on the HDD!
So IMO for portable storage, I'm not touching the piece of cheap crap flash drives. I'll stick with real technology, with real warranties that haven't failed me once since before the 3.5" floppy disk was released!
This is a classic Innovator's Dilemma/Innovator's Solution situation. People were buying for capacity, soon they'll be buying for convenience (speed, power consumption, etc). Tape drives are cheaper than HDD but no one is buying those.
I haven't bought a CD in over a year and when I did it was because it was one of my favorite bands. How long is it before I'm saying the same thing with DVD?
SSD might pick up some niche uses, but there's a reason people have wanted mass storage, which is that programs are progressively getting bigger and so are all the files we store. I remember thinking a 400x300 pixel image was big, now I think a photo smaller than like 2000x1500 as small. In 5-10 years I'm going to think anything smaller than like 10,000x7,500 as pathetically small. Equally, I'm going to think any video that's not at least 720p isn't worth having, because by 2015 companies want UHDV to be released displaying at 4320p. When my video is taking up 32MB per frame I don't want, I'll need maximum capacity still.
Ok, that's 75 megapixels. Ken Rockwell estimates that 35mm film is about 175 mp (http://www.kenrockwell.com/tech/film-resolution.htm), so that is a technically realistic number. But you need an outstanding camera and photographer to make all those megapixels matter, and most people won't pay for and won't even notice the extra detail. Resolution bigger than the biggest computer doesn't matter much for mainstream users, and even a 6.1mp image from my DSLR looks good printed out at 8x10".
Now a hard drive full of HD movies would take up tons of space, but do you want to carry that around with you? Not to mention that movie studios will do whatever than can to prevent persistent files from being the digital format of choice. They would much rather stream on demand and charge per viewing or per rental.
We've always wanted more space, but computers are getting to the point where they're fast enough and big enough to satisfy common users. The fact that you're here on HN means that you're by definition not a common user.
They are getting mainstream with the MacBook Air and others following, I guess the wait is finally over.
I'm not so sure about long term storage reliability. I would currently prefer to combine both type of storage.
I too bought a 32GB SSD from SanDisk a year ago to replace hard drive in my IBM ThinkPad X60s to get silence and shock resistance (I guess I'm paranoid on those issues, but it made me happy) Sequential write perfomance is noticeably less than even in 5400 rpm drives, but I didn't care much; it's okay for me.
Yet I would call people who use SSD in their computers early adopters; the outlook for SSDs is optimistic but I guess it will be a few years at best till SSDs will be able to become mainstream.