That said, the proper remedy here is for them to buy back the domain name at a fair market price (whatever that may be, again I have no idea). The owner shouldn't be able to "ransom" the name for an unfair price, either.
Why? It is his property, he can do what he wants with it.
I don't see how the company would have any right to get that domain back if the guy doesn't want to sell it. Then again, IANAL.
Fucking with a guy who thought MikeRoweSoft was funny? Probably not cool. Losing out on MichelinGuides for a dude who set up a prank? Eh, I'm siding with Michelin in this case.
I don't see why this guy should have to give up his legally obtained domain because some company failed to do their job. If he's smart, he'll skip court and settle for a lot of money/perks.
If he wants to keep it, it should be his prerogative. If he wants to say "I'm happy to keep it, unless you happen to have half a million Euros lying around" he should be able to do that as well.
In the end, FMP is determined by what anyone is willing to pay.
Why should someone return (or sell back at a "fair" price) a domain they legally bought, just to have it fall back into disuse?
Since there is a supply of n=1, please define what an "unfair" price is, if you're not comfortable with defining it as the amount that Michelin is willing to pay.
The prank is acceptable. The ransom is not.