Landing on the Moon without a Rocket
underamp.com
underamp.com
Remember the early Mars missions that used the inflated-bag method? They had to expend a lot of fuel to slow down enough to safely approach the surface, at which point the air-bag method was used (and worked). But this only reduced the amount of fuel required to get to the surface, it didn't significantly change that cost and burden.
Just do some numerical orbital simulations -- see what happens when you slowly reduce the velocity and altitude of a craft orbiting the moon so it is able to graze the surface. See what happens when you impact the surface at shallow angles. Hint: the craft's velocity is still extremely high and the air bags have to absorb too much energy -- they will self-destruct.
In a hypothetical approach to a perfectly smooth plains area (the moon has plenty of those), in which there are no altitude irregularities and the craft can approach at nearly orbital speed and impact the surface at a very shallow angle, the craft would begin to roll along the surface at such a high velocity that the centripetal forces would tear the craft apart.
Speaking as a former NASA Space Shuttle engineer.
But they're not stupid - I wonder what they're not telling us.
That won't prevent the craft from contacting the surface at very high speed and beginning to roll. As soon as the roll starts (as soon as linear velocity becomes rotational velocity), the velocity will decline further, which will change the angle of attack and increase the conversion of orbital kinetic energy into centripetal force. Believe me, the craft will disintegrate if it touches the surface at near-orbital speeds, which is implied by the proposed angle of attack.
> Personally, and not speaking as a former NASA Space Shuttle engineer, it seems unlikely that they'll find ground flat enough for this to work.
Yes, but my reason for stating it like that was to focus on one factor and eliminate others for the moment.
> But they're not stupid - I wonder what they're not telling us.
I think the author is someone who thinks about these problems, but not with the benefit of experience in orbital analysis or intuition about the kinds of problems that come up.
The biggest problem seems like it would be the centrifugal force. More simulations would have to be done, but there should be lots of frictional losses, not to mention the kinetic energy lost that goes into generating the rotational energy. It might be possible to overcome this force, especially with a smaller payload.
Excuse me? To remain in a circular orbit over the airless moon, no thrust is required at all. Read this for a full explanation:
http://arachnoid.com/gravitation_equations/orbital_mechanics...
> The biggest problem seems like it would be the centrifugal force.
Not centrifugal force (a fictional force) but centripetal force, the force produced by the craft's parts being forced to turn against a natural tendency to move away in a straight line. Which, given the problem's velocity, they will begin to do in short order after tearing themselves to pieces.
> It might be possible to overcome this force, especially with a smaller payload.
Not in the described scenario -- even a tiny payload would disintegrate upon touching the surface at orbital velocity. Consider that the orbital velocity for a lunar circular orbit is 1.2 km/s or almost 2700 miles per hour -- that would be Mach 3.5 if there were any air available to give that meaning. Given the proposed approach angle, the contact velocity is nearly the same as the circular orbit velocity given above. There's no way that a craft can safely dissipate that kind of kinetic energy by simply rolling along the lunar surface.
It's way too fast, too much kinetic energy, the idea isn't practical. Sorry, but physics and mathematics say no.
So-called "fictional forces" are used all the time to simplify calculations. Furthermore, if you are going to be pedantic, in GR centrifugal force is just as real as gravitational force.
Of course, in GR, gravitational force is also a fictional force. But one makes few friends by constantly pointing this out whenever anyone says "gravitational force".
Consider the context -- someone wants to soft-land on the moon at 2700 miles per hour. Under those circumstances, I suggest avoiding any other gratuitous fictions until more has been learned.
> But one makes few friends by constantly pointing this out whenever anyone says "gravitational force".
Yes, unless you're instructing a student. Someone who plans to slide into home base at 1.23 km/s is a student and should receive the pedantic version.
In this context, I'm sure that determining the "centrifugal force" at each point on the inside of the ball to calculate the pressure on the outside wall, and comparing that to the tensile strength of the outside wall, should work just fine. At least for that one aspect of the problem.
That's a centripetal force -- the unified wall's resistance to its component parts' tendency to move away in a straight line.
Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centripetal_force
Quote: "Centripetal force (from Latin centrum "center" and petere "to seek") is a force that makes a body follow a curved path: its direction is always orthogonal to the velocity of the body, toward the fixed point of the instantaneous center of curvature of the path. Centripetal force is generally the cause of circular motion."
Perhaps in this case, argument for argument's sake isn't constructive.
> At least for that one aspect of the problem.
As is often the case when quoting fictitious forces, it can only confuse the student. Maybe as a side effect, it might make him think he can land an intact spacecraft on the moon by sliding to a stop.
It's also centrifugal force, if you are working in the rotating reference frame of the ball, which in the case of calculating the internal pressure, is probably a bit easier to do.
> it can only confuse the student.
I'm not confused.
> I'm not confused.
You're not a student, the OP is.
E.g., the classic problem of determining at what point you will fall off when skiing straight down a giant frictionless spherical snow ball. For me this is much easier to analyze by asking yourself at what point the centrifugal force pushing you off of the snowball will counteract the vector of gravity that is pushing you onto the snowball's tangent.
The so-called "right" way of thinking about this problem is at what point the centripetal vector of gravity is no longer sufficient to constrain your movement to a circle. That's much harder to visualize for me. And would be even more so for non-spherical shapes.
The real right way to think about this, is to think about it both ways and then to convince yourself that they are equivalent. Not to pretend that there is no such thing as centrifugal force.
Yes, but at 1.2 km/s -- way, way too fast for anything but complete destruction of the craft.
The craft approaches the surface at an angle near zero. The craft's lower extent begins to rub against the surface and (assuming a perfectly flat terrain) begins to dissipate energy through friction, and by "rolling" -- by converting linear velocity into rotational velocity.
The lost energy causes the angle of attack to increase and push the craft into the surface more forcefully. This increases heating and rotational velocity.
Within seconds, the combination of high rotational velocity and frictional heating causes the craft to disintegrate, to fly apart.
1.2 km/s is just too high a velocity with which to approach the moon's surface.