A 29-year-old on the difficulties of landing a first job
theglobeandmail.com
theglobeandmail.com
Seriously? Forever lost is a pretty strong statement. I don't see how any of these opportunities are forever lost just because he's 29 and hasn't had a steady job until now. Millions (billions?) of people manage to get married, have children, study, etc while in objectively far worse situations than this kid ever will be. This article overflows with a sense of entitlement. Reminds me of an editorial from a few years back, where a lawyer (professor?) in Chicago claimed destitution at $400K/yr [1].
[1] http://delong.typepad.com/sdj/2010/09/in-which-mr-deling-res...
PS: Comment from an older thread that expresses my sentiments precisely: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3991666
The real problem is that the kinds of jobs that liberal arts education trains people for are:
* academia and research, which have been contracting for 30 years.
* autonomous high-skill labor, which has also been getting rarer, and which would require further education on his part.
* executive jobs that have since been judged supernumerary and probably don't actually make economic sense.
People like him used to get "junior executive" jobs where they might have no direct reports, but were clearly being groomed for something better. (Think Pete Campbell in Mad Men.) Those jobs don't exist anymore and that's probably a good thing, because they don't make sense, but that is exactly what society prepped him for-- something that no longer exists.
He's now in the state where he can't get quality work experience because he doesn't have quality work experience.
If I were unethical, I might start a business as a "reinvention consultant" and give guys like him a fake work history (shell companies, references, ~3 months of training in the very few things he actually needs to know to be a corporate executive) and a second chance. There will be a lot of demand for that kind of service 5-10 years from now.
Screwed? Nonsense.
At 29 years old, I had zero work experience, other than a few research assistant jobs in my 10-year slacker bachelor's degree (which did not result in positive references). Oh, and 4 months at a Subway. The only thing even vaguely positive about my economic history was that I did do a degree in computing science... but I had deliberately made it as useless as possible, because I was an idiot.
6 years later, I work at the best company in the world (I believe you're familiar with the place, mchurch).
He (she?) may well be disadvantaged by his age, that's fair. But then again, he's already had lots of advantages, like being educated, living in Canada, etc.
This is a painful and horrible lesson to learn, especially if you are carrying student debt for going to a "good school" for your degree to enhance your "job prospects." If you want to be employable by a wide number of places, you need to learn three things:
1) Mathematics with at least one year of calculus and one year of probability/statistics.
2) Communication competency, being able to propose, debate, and revise a plan or proposal.
3) The scientific method of knowledge discovery through a combination of theory, experimentalism, and reasoning by analogy.
I interviewed a guy who basically cheated his way through school so that he could 'get on with it since you don't learn anything in school anyway' and completely missed that you actually can learn how to learn in college. It helps if you develop your integrity and maturity as well. At least he was up front about it.
The whole 'screwed at 29' thing is just youth angst. Trust me you feel the same at 40 as you did at 30. And you've got 10 years between those two, you could get a medical degree in 10 years if you applied yourself to it.
Do people really expect to get something like that by the time they're 30? There are very few industries where that's the norm. Perhaps some of my peers have totally unrealistic expectations! Too many movies, too much TV, and too much time spent reading about other people's lives on Quora.
I don't have dreams about my current job that's a good 40-hour week (sometimes 45), lets me drive a used Toyota, and helps me pay a mortgage on a modest home, have a wife and a child, and enjoy a meal out every now and then. I can still save some money for retirement, even if it's just a tiny bit each month. I enjoy my life, and hope for something better, but I work one day at a time to achieve that dream, and I don't complain about it!
That doesn't speak to entitlement to me, but rather just getting on the path that, with hard work, can lead there.
The problem is that many are unable to even get their foot in the door. The hope is eventually it will change with the boomers retiring and opening up positions, but there is always the danger that this generation will be skipped.
However, the same fear happened to Gen X, that GenX would be skipped over, but after some major growing pains that generation too found their way in.
Perhaps instead, the problem is that those who graduate into a recession are leapfrogged by those who graduate into a great market. There are other studies that show the disparity in lifetime earnings based on this.
Of course that idea is impossible. High earnings are not an absolute value, only a value greater than a typical income. If we all received high incomes, that income would just become typical, leaving a small group with an even higher income to strive towards.
This person is making an average income, which is where you would expect the average person growing up in our generation to be. We cannot all be above average. It is a logical impossibility.
Actually, my experience is that high incomes did come our way. Sort-of.
The problem is that the price of everything went way up. If you include the fact that career needs now necessitate living in a high-COL area, inflation is much more than the 2% on paper.
They graduated college, and couldn't find anything. They took what was available, typically call center jobs. Then, when entry level jobs came in their desired field, they were passed over because their experience was in low skilled positions.
Those leaving college are given a free pass since they aren't expected to have experience. However, once you take that low skill position, it's much harder to climb back up.
If you don't get it when you're 30, then you're not going to get it at 35 or 40. Age without progress decreases opportunities. He's 29 and has shown no progress, and you seem to be surprised that he's expecting progress.
We can mock his douchey goals, and perhaps we should, but the fact is that a whole generation was bred for executive positions that are no longer available (and shouldn't exist).
What he probably needed to do, in order to pursue his douchey vision of a cushy cigar-smoking executive job, was get an investment banking or management consulting job. Those aren't my favorite industries, but a few years of time in them will open the kinds of doors he wants. The BMW and the fatal heart attack at 45 could be his, if he had made the right moves years ago. However, it's too late for him now. With an empty resume, he can't compete against 22-year-old college grads. That's just how it works.
In the Mad Men era, a college degree got you a junior executive job. You became an "account executive" or a marketing person. Sure, you were still someone's bitch-- being at the bottom of the executive-track totem pole-- and you probably had no direct reports, but you were on a track toward something better.
Those junior executive jobs are gone. Why? After 3 decades of downsizing, the corporate "fat" has been trimmed. That's probably a good thing, but what it means is that all those junior-executive jobs have been filled by people who used to be senior executives. Companies don't have the slots to take on 22-year-old proteges anymore. Again, it's probably good for the world that we're not generating all these supernumerary "executives" who do nothing but annoy the people doing the actual work, but it's not good for people who were bred (through parental expectations and undergraduate education and, in some cases, graduate degrees) for these positions.
Undergraduate college is the liberal arts. (Sciences are liberal arts.) "Liberal" in this sense has nothing to do with political ideology, but rather means "for the free". The contrast is servile arts.
It makes me angry when self-righteous Baby Boomers complain about "entitled" Millennials. On Sunday, they write on the Internet about these supposedly entitled schmucks who won't settle for anything less than a career-track job. Then on Monday, they turn down the 27-year-old barista who did take one of those crummy jobs and now has "no relevant work experience". They made and supported this world and they can fucking eat it.
The real problem is that the whole concept of "management", in the traditional sense, has become pointless.
College breeds you to be one of three things: (A) an academic or researcher, (B) a highly-skilled professional with high autonomy, or (C) a manager. Class A is dying out. Class B is losing autonomy, as the professions are eroded and traditionally intellectual fields (e.g. software engineering) are commoditized in an idiotic lurch toward a manage-or-be-managed corporate world, and class C is becoming obsolete enough that these junior executive jobs don't make sense and have been cut.
Grossing $36k annually in Toronto or Vancouver doesn't go very far. Assume 27k net = $2,250 per month. $800 for rent, $400 for student loan, $300 for food, $300 savings, $200 entertainment, $250 for gas and insurance (assuming you own a car) and you're at 0.
And don't even think about getting into the housing market. Maybe the condo market with help from parents or 5-10y savings for a down payment...
I haven't lived in those cities but I would guess public transport is good enough that owning a car is not a requirement, its more like entertainment spending. (I know people who have lived in the GTA without needing a car. I don't know exactly what their rent costs were, possibly a little over $800 but not more than $1000).
Sure he will not be getting a home in the immediate future but unless something terrible happens his salary will only go up . In 5 years, when he probably will have a 2 person family judging by his eagerness for marriage, a small home will be within reach.
[1] http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/british-columbia/the-cru...
Lone Person in Toronto treated as Family (single parent) has median of 39k http://www.statcan.gc.ca/tables-tableaux/sum-som/l01/cst01/f...
I noticed that you put down 300$ into savings, but later, at end of month, you claim that there 0$ left, as if savings evaporated. Other numbers
As per housing / condo market I totally agree. Toronto and Vancouver are way overpriced. To anyone interested on Canadian housing market I recommend checking out http://www.greaterfool.ca/
Reminds me of a saying You don't need more money to be happy, you need to want less stuff - I saw it on HN, but forgot the author. Maybe the key is to understand that the last sentence (I wanted to be someone) doesn't have anything to do with the other ones. You don't magically become someone by putting on a tailored suit or stuffing your body inside a BMW.
Not to forget that someone actually wanting 65 hours of work per week will hardly end up healthy, happy etc.
He should step back and realize he can't compete at that level. I find that people that sometimes work at small companies tend to take on roles that they may not necessarily have been able to get otherwise. Once they are laid off, they expect to have the same job at another company. What is sometimes lost is that those companies may only hire for that role when the person has an MBA or a particular designation, etc. The person feels they should get the job since they have been doing it already.
Well, it just doesn't work that way. You can either keep smashing your head against the wall or just maybe go find yourself something else to smash your head against. In his case, instead of accepting that the jobs he is applying for he is perhaps marginally a fit for, I suspect he continues to apply even after seeing that he only meets perhaps 1 or 2 of the five criteria. Doing so is just stupid.
This person's story is the classic and simple case of using old methods of finding a job when these methods just don't work that well anymore. I find it amusing that with all the education that this person has, he doesn't realize that the old methods usually work in a very hot economy. A good classic that is always updated is the What Color Is Your Parachute? book. The approaches described in that book would likely get this person very good results once he starts realizing that he should be a little less ambitious to start in terms of what he is looking for and also change his attitude (ie. drop the victim mentality - nobody owes him anything).