Obama signs cybersecurity executive order
zdnet.com
zdnet.com
I flagged this, for what it's worth. I upvoted other stories on the cybersecurity EO (I did a clause-by-clause comparison of the just-signed EO with last year's published EO draft, so it'd've been nice to have some place to discuss it). I flagged some other bad ones. And which one makes it to the front page of HN? This one. Sigh.
It's not written to be a general "applies everywhere" memo. It might of course be construed as such at some point, but it's not, on the face of it, written as such.
In other words, if you run a nuclear power plant that is connected to the Internet via an unauthenticated gateway and the government somehow learns of that fact, this EO would not allow the government to take any actions, other than to (a) inform you that you are operating designated critical infrastructure and (b) offer to enroll you in a program to have the government unidirectionally share nonclassified attack information with you.
But, sure: the 1-day-old EO has not "undergone any public technical rights-based or privacy reviews".
In particular, CISPA contains no provisions that would enable the US Government to request private information from private companies. The information that CISPA allows private companies to share is limited to network attack data.
The idea that CISPA would be a vector for DHS and DOJ to get warrantless access to email and Facebook messages, though, is hyperbolic and more than a little silly, because DHS and DOJ already have a warrantless way to get most of that information --- court orders.
It's ˙totally˙ reasonable to be concerned about the ease with which the government can get access to information via court orders. But that's a concern that's orthogonal to CISPA; if anyone meant CISPA as an an additive to the mechanisms the government already uses to get email, the bill would be written differently.
It is as always worth mentioning that CISPA is an opt-in measure.