> Bottom-posting, due to its falling out of favor in the mainstream, has become a shibboleth that signifies a certain degree of competence with technology and Internet communication in general.
I don't find this true at all. I get quite the mix of response styles from people of all walks of 'techno competency' -- sometimes a MUA defaults, especially mobile ones. As mentioned elsewhere in the comments, in business settings (often with engineers) top-posting is also very common. Not everyone uses Mutt. I think attempting to label people who don't follow your preference as less technical competent is a bit myopic.Further, it could even be considered rude to start bottom posting in a chain of existing top-posting-only.
That said, I do prefer bottom posting when it makes sense, and practice it when it is convenient or the social norm of the community I am conversing within.