But after spending a lot of time with it recently (e.g. getting LXC running last night), I've concluded that it would be very hard to design a system with a security API that is worse than Linux.
The issue is that Linus doesn't design ANYTHING. He doesn't believe in design; he only believes in evolution.
Unix was designed, whereas Linux is mostly a bunch of code bolted on top of Unix. It's not sustainable in the long term. Someone needs to actually design something eventually, so there is a stable base for more evolution.
Spend some time looking through these:
- traditional Unix ACL-based security
- traditional resource limits
- chroot (not secure, but used as a "part" of many security solutions)
- capabilities
- seccomp
- LSM-based
- SELinux
- AppArmor
- ...
- LXC
- cgroups
- namespaces (apparently completed with this kernel release)
- LXC user space tools
- ptrace sandboxing
- (at least a dozen projects use this)
- user mode linux
And you'll realize it's just a huge mess. I'm sure the complexity makes Linux measurably more insecure in practice. Or it just provides employment for a lot of people -- who knows.There's never going to be a way to clean this all up, since people are relying on all of it.
I don't have that much experience with the alternatives; I'm sure they're messy in their own right. (I've used many OSes, but not security-wise.) But this definitely has me looking towards FreeBSD and such. Too bad it is more expensive on EC2.
I mentioned Minix 3 here before -- it's probably a pipe dream, but being a microkernel, it seems like a good basis for a future secure Unix. It actually was designed in some sense.
From what I gather people take the existence of root escalation exploits on Linux for granted. If that weren't so (and it shouldn't be with a microkernel), then traditional Unix security might actually cover a lot of cases that all these hacks on top are patching up.
EDIT: Also, Linux should look to DJB for guidance. Out of all the hairiniess, how do you even do this on Linux (or any Unix)? http://cr.yp.to/unix/disablenetwork.html It just seems crazy.