How about not using passwords? All students, staff, and faculty should have ID cards; start issuing smartcards, and start using cryptographic techniques to authenticate users. Also, digitally sign all official mail, and instruct the users to check those signatures.
These are not insurmountable problems. The real issue is that the IT team is not willing to push for a real solution, and instead went for a bandaid on a broken leg.
But anyway, I don't want to start slagging off a particular team that I've never met - maybe they wanted to do all sorts of other, smarter, things and weren't allowed, and maybe they'll be allowed to do them now..
It's usually customised for each university.
It's not a trivial problem by any means, but from the network security team's blog it doesn't seem like they've taken many of the steps that I'd expect prior to cutting off a very high traffic website.
There's the nice clever intelligent solution which could be developed over a few weeks, or there's the fact that the phishers have decided -- for whatever reason -- to go apeshit today.
They actually mention sinkholing spreadsheets.google.com in this post from August 2011 [1], they actually say "There are also some forms which are more difficult to block ( I don’t think we’d be too popular if we sink-holed spreadsheets.google.com for example)".
So they've had the issue for years.
1 - https://blogs.oucs.ox.ac.uk/oxcert/2011/08/12/the-price-of-p...
Costs. At my university (though of course slightly smaller than Oxford) that would never work.
> Also, digitally sign all official mail, and instruct the users to check those signatures.
Have you met users? That's as good as saying they shouldn't be idiots and never enter their credentials in a site linked in a mail. If that would work all anti virus vendors could close shop.
I bet if they ask for the resources to implement all those solutions, they will be told: find something at zero cost, I repeat zero-cost. Roger that?
Not that I agree blocking google docs is reasonable, just pointing out the problems with your suggestions.
False.
People fall for 419 phishing scams. What makes you think they are able to check for digital signatures.
Also, the number of people who fall for 419 scams is fairly low, just barely above the threshold of profitability. The reason people are shocked when they hear that anyone falls for such scams is that hardly anyone does. There is a hypothesis that 419 scams are designed to be obvious, because it helps in filtering potential victims: anyone who would be naive enough to reply is an easy target.
I think a broader problem is that most people are not just unaware of cryptography, but they use an email client that has no support for checking digital signatures. Webmail is by far the most popular email client type, but many popular webmail systems have no support for digital signatures at all, not even checking them for validity. It would be a lot easier to tell people to check for a digital signature if that meant looking for a border color, or a big gold star, or if hovering over/clicking on a link in an unsigned message displayed an annoying warning but no warnings were displayed in signed messages; sufficiently annoying warnings do help in making cryptosystems more effective in practice:
You then have 2 problems: (a) What email clients will support it and (b) con artists will just put big green borders around their spam emails.
(Edit: It is also conceivable that a client could put another prominent border around HTML mail, to mitigate the issue somewhat.)
For example, blocking all outgoing SMTP traffic except via approved internal relay servers would make tracking these millions of unexpected outgoing emails much easier. Most organisations already put these kinds of restrictions in place, it seems Oxford don't.
As far as I can see, their temporary blocking of Google Docs access did nothing but annoy users, cause them to lose face amongst users, and in the long term make users less likely to cooperate with the security team.
http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/xpl/login.jsp?tp=&arnumber=61...
edited to add: here's the paper for you to read, i forgot i had a copy lying around.
Although I'll note that I didn't read the research since it's behind a $31 paywall.
This can be a problem for universities in specific ways. Students get emailed some change to course work, all students using hotmail don't get the email, students then have a case to appeal the (possibly) worse mark they received.
Sure. Which is why after so many people complained it is already back up.
Did you miss the recent articles about how spreadsheets were essential to many people? I know many SMEs and individuals which are doing nearly everything besides email in Google Docs. And what do they use email for? To send PDF of Google Docs to those that don't have GMail accounts.
In the recent "tools of the trade" for HN readers one of the webapp that came out the most often was Google Docs. It is also, quite arguably, seen all its functionalities and seen that it's made by a team of, what, 600 Googlers (!) the most advanced webapp ever.
I think you really don't realize how important Google Docs has become. And it is growing by the day.
There are people who create a GMail account only to get Google Docs after they've seen a demo of it.