I don't think that it is possible for an idea to be a "killer idea" until it reaches execution phase. But then, it is no longer an idea but a combination of idea and execution.
There might be some ideas that just make money entirely by themselves. They are far less common than businesses that make money hand-over-fist. And these are less common than ordinary successful businesses and these are outnumbered by people think they have great ideas for making money ....