This is a favorite game of mine and I've given it some thought. I think an alternate formulation might give the typical HN reader new insight in the game.
Let's say I tell you I have an idea for a company. It's a really cool idea and if we realize it we will make boatloads of money. I need your help to realize it. If you agree, you will get 20% of the company. If you don't, we won't realize it and neither of us will make any money.
Do you accept? If not, why not?