How to end the "work from home" debate
justinjackson.ca
justinjackson.ca
That is not to say remote working is something to be looked down upon (quite the opposite in my opinion), but productivity comes down to the individual worker in a remote situation, not the management team behind them.
I believe Yahoo was justified in their decision to reign in the slack due to this idea.
Companies like Automattic, 37signals, and GitHub hire "managers of one". These are that can produce great work, without having someone looking over their shoulder.
Yes: remote work isn't for everyone. That's why I think it comes down to managers empowering their people to do their best work. If a developer can be honest, and say: "You let me work remotely, but I keep getting distracted. I either need you to teach me better work-from-home-habits or I'll need to come back to the office."
That's what managers should aim for.
If they don't have any of the right people, they're in real trouble.
Can an amazing coach with a mediocre team produce a championship? I don't think it's possible to lead a mediocre team to produce great products.
I get that metrics don't always work well, and they may be harder to enforce for people you don't see day-in and day-out, but there's nothing stopping them from setting a goal of "complete work on X by day Y", and hold people to that, regardless of whether they're in the office or at home.
I'd love to see more discussion on this: what are good ways for managers to know if their team is being productive?
I understand that Yahoo management screwed the pooch. From my position, outside of that management, it appears that the fallout is now in part on some of the most productive people.
I put up with that bullshit long enough. Were I at Yahoo, I'd immediately decide that they were asking me to pay for others' mistakes. And I'd be looking to move.
That's just me. I abhor the needless and counter-productive distraction of open offices. But... some of the best people I've worked with were and are the same way. And... they were generally acknowledged to be the best in their domains at those companies.
There are not that many rock stars in the world. Even fewer of them want to work for you. (Most rock stars work for themselves already.)
Thus, this argument is a fantasy for most companies, especially large companies. It's like saying if you only hire scrupulously honest people, you don't need accounting controls. It's logically consistent, but a bad idea in the real world.
Of course, most employees think they are rock stars.[1] That gap between perception and reality is what makes it hard to manage people.
1. http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-205_162-57568186/everyone-thinks...
Maybe I should expand on this part here: "Yes, every job, product, and company will have certain constraints. The point is to create as much job flexibility as you can so your people can succeed."
What's missing from a lot of manager-employee relationships is conversation: figuring out what works for individual employees within a given context (a specific culture, specific product, etc...).
What was sad about the Yahoo edict was that it was broad and general: "Everyone needs to stop working from home." That's a big culture shift without any interaction.