> There are security standards which mandate certain kinds of passwords (complexity) and are silent on asymmetric keys, so you couldn't use keys in those environments.
Every single auditor I've worked with has given a pass when they saw we were using keys instead of passwords. Do you also fail audits because your RSA token is only 10-12 digits?
You could, I suppose, demand users upload their private key (shudder) to the organization so you can check if it's encrypted; this has its own flaws (primarily that you've just taught your users to be giving with their private key), and you still can't enforce passphrase strength well.