So later I did compare it to a very simple for loop operating against a byte[], and had both versions work against a 10MB buffer (not unrealistic input in my use case). The throughput of the "yield return" code was something like 5 times less. I didn't try too hard to track down the precise cause of that at the time (maybe it was GC from lots of temporaries as you say? I was pretty CPU bound, and thinking it could have had more to do with a more straightforward loop generating code with fewer jumps after JIT), I just took the faster version.