> It shows every sign of a typical patent troll and will always choose the option that guarantees its members income, not the most innovative or best option,
1) It's members are the ones that invented h.264 (NTT, Microsoft).
2) Every company that owns something of value tries to maximize their revenue from it.
MPEG-LA is a perfectly reasonable arrangement. It allows things like h.264 to be standardized while also offering an avenue for that R&D work to be monetized. The alternative would be people keeping new coding techniques secret and trying to compete with each other using them to offer better video quality in their own products. There is not a world where Microsoft, NTT, etc, are going to do R&D to help competitors like Google out of the goodness of their hearts, for the sake of "innovation."
It should be noted here that Google makes a ton of money off video compression algorithms (they make Youtube possible in the first place), but has done jack shit to contribute to their development itself. Of course they want to get the license to something like h.264 for free, but why shouldn't they have to pay for it?