Neanderthal large eyes 'caused their demise'
bbc.co.uk
bbc.co.uk
It also leads us to think about questions that seem to have never occurred to other hominids. For instance we put a surprising amount of energy into wondering about what happens when we die, and how we can get a better result. As a consequence every known human society - both now and in the archeological record - has burial rituals of some sort. But no other form of hominid, including Neanderthals, has shown evidence of that.
The latter assertion is false:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neanderthal_behavior#Burial_pra...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanidar_Cave
http://www.smithsonianmag.com/arts-culture/The-Skeletons-of-...
Nevertheless, I am curious how they ascertained that Neanderthals could not plan ahead as well as humans. Their definition must be very restrictive because New Caledonian Crows, Chimps, Bonobos, Dolphins, Elephants and possibly even octopuses have been shown to be able to plan ahead.
That said, to fit their "nature documentary format" they have to show things as fact which are in fact unknown and/or actively debated. And it was based on what was thought a decade ago.
So thank you for your information. I'll amend that tidbit that I saw with an appropriate question mark.
Neanderthals had ritual burial.
Millions of years of natural selection. Social norms are ephemeral, while instinct is backed up by genetic support.
However, lots of stuff in our lives are a mix of both, so the answer is: let's study feral children!
At what point do we cease to call it "instinct" and begin to call it "preparation"? Such preparation for the future may be innate in us to survive future events. It is just that we have a higher level of comprehension on what we want (and how to do it). It is not as black and white as it may seem.
In any case, this article was quite interesting. It is funny that people seem to think neanderthals were stupid, when in fact they were quite a progression from those before.
I forget what it was that caused the demise of the Neanderthals two weeks ago. Maybe that they had red hair and sunburned easily.
I guess that means it's been three weeks since the last announcement that another "nearby earth-like planet" has been discovered.
Also, related to some other comments, the same NPR article claims that "there's evidence they thought about life in complicated ways" based on how they cared for an elder and their burial rituals.
[1] http://www.npr.org/blogs/krulwich/2013/03/08/173813194/what-...
I assume that only letting in more light would be a bigger pupil, not a bigger eyeball, hence the bigger eyeball has a lot more data to process.
In fact I'm kind of on the fence, we humans tend to approximate a lot of information not under our direct focus with memory and perception tricks? I guess you call them. I'm not sure whether this means we are maxing capacity as it is and have to approximate in order to handle the information, or if its simply more efficient energy wise. Anyway, my point is, while there may be more information coming in, it doesn't necessarily mean they used it all, or cost them anything in the way of processing power elsewhere.
I'm still holding onto the idea we were simply better looking and got all the chicks. (interspecies breeding)
Whether they are right I don't think we have enough evidence either way, really.
> Studies on primates have shown that eye size is proportional to the amount of
> brain space devoted to visual processing. So the researchers made the
> assumption that this would be true of Neanderthals.