Some ask, "What's the difference?" If I tell you about 5 albums that you've already heard of, are the recommendations good? Even if we're pretty certain you'll like them? If you're buying an obscure jazz album and you get "Kind of Blue" as a recommendation (probably most popular jazz album in history and one any jazz fan would know of) is that a good recommendation?
How do users build trust of recommendations? How does that factor into the algorithms? It turns out you need a mix of obvious and surprising results. All obvious and they don't discover anything; all surprising and they don't trust them.
Those are the right questions. A good algorithm for recommendations is one that people interact with and discover things with.
This is an awesome read (in fact, I uhm, submitted it a few minutes before at Greg's blog, but it's good enough that I upvoted it here too). As soon as I ran across it I immediately blogged, tweeted, and submitted here. I'd had a draft of an essay along these lines kicking around for ages.