No, it's not. Paid services are cancelled all the time.
No, it's not. Paid services are cancelled all the time.
When a paid product dies, it's (often) because the product wasn't doing well in the market. When a free product dies, it's because the company couldn't support it through their secondary revenue streams. The product may be the Best Thing EVARRR, but it's a casualty of failures elsewhere. The "bad" comment is likely because it's a lot easier to measure direct risks (i.e., risks associated with your product) than indirect ones (risks associated with your secondary business model, which likely isn't your area of expertise; if it was, you should be in business there).
Whether this applies to Google, I'm on the fence.
But where does the original claim get its support? Are paid services less likely to shut down? We read on HN all the time about post-mortems of, yes, paid services. If we don't know that, then it's just a misleading post hoc argument (and in the counterfactual universe where Reader was a paid service, all the naysayers are now chorusing 'It's a Google service! You can't trust Google! We-told-you-so!').
http://unicornfree.com/2013/why-we-shut-down-charm-on-the-ev...
EDIT: Although I agree that it's a much bigger problem with free services.
I find that hard, because I'm not a business person nor do I usually make the money-for-time tradeoff; hence I mostly only use free services and am mostly affected by free service shutdowns - in other words, selection bias makes my personal experiences unrepresentative. (Is this similar to other techies - like Hacker News users? I think it is.)
However, we can make the general observation that services only sometimes survive the business running them, and businesses shut down all the time. To give two personal examples of paid services I used that have stopped or will be stopping in the near future: Intrade has halted all trading during an investigation, and probably will wind up shutting down; Zeo Inc is shutting down as it looks for buyers of its assets, and while the web interface I've always used to export my data is not yet down, I don't give very high odds for it staying up for more than the next year.
In both cases, I paid good money to use them; it didn't save them.
- RSS is a thing from the past. It has no "new and shiny" aspect.
- RSS is less used than email, so people are focusing on improving emails, not RSS.
- Reader was great, and did everything geeks want. Why try to improve something perfect?
- + "it is Google, Google will never kill it, because Google guys are geeks too, like us" myth.
And email is in the same class. Rich text formatted letters between individuals. I don't see how you want to "improve" that either, because it does its job right.
I do agree Reader did the job and therefor didn't have room to improve. Then again, I don't like all the social parts of feeds, I just want my content in a time ordered list of chunks that I can consume at my leisure. RSS does that just fine.
Press (on Android) updates its app, saying that it will not go down.
It's a double problem: Google Reader was good, AND was also a good API. At least, Google Takeout is working, and giving us all our data.