Reverse Engineering the Human Diet
earth360.com
earth360.com
We sold that company, and I stopped seriously reading on the subject. Recently, illnesses in my family (cancer and autoimmune diseases) have caused me to get into the subject again to an even greater degree. I've also experimented with my own diet for the last several years and I've arrived at a very different conclusion than this fellow.
There are tons of people that have an almost religious agenda about pushing specific diets. They are usually well-intentioned...they just really want to believe they are right. They publish pseudo-scientific articles like this one that have just enough logic in them to seduce people into believing them. The media is also horrible about publishing sensational (but poorly analyzed) nutrition research. They flip-flop their headlines so much ("Coffee Can Cure X", then "Coffee Causes X Cancer") that people finally just give up on trying to understand nutrition and they just continue eating the crap that they have always eaten. Which is amazingly sad, because proper nutrition is really the best medicine on earth.
I LOOOOOOOVE steak and ice cream, but a vegetarian/vegan diet has been shown in almost every study to be a more healthful diet in every respect. And the studies that fail to show that are usually flawed and/or underwritten by industry trade groups. There is no "perfect diet" for everyone...there will always be corner cases. Some people with specific genetic predispositions SHOULD avoid grains altogether. Apart from gluten sensitivity, there is the issue of molecular mimicry and genetic autoimmune issues, etc.
Modern people are dying of heart disease, cancer and strokes, though. Those illnesses are linked to higher consumption of meat (Paleo-coronary, anyone?), dairy, sugar, cooking oil, and refined foods. We are NOT dying of starvation, hypothermia, or tooth loss - which were probably some of the more pressing concerns in the paleolithic era. We are also living 2-4 times longer than our ancestors, on average, so we have entirely different concerns.
This is really a fascinating area of research...I've noticed that tons of computer hackers are also very interested in nutrition and body/diet hacks.
Vegetarians have a higher death rate than meat eaters of the same socio-economic class at all ages.
Every study that looks at actual disease and death rates, and not assumed correlates like cholesterol, has found health benefits from high animal fat intake.
> heart disease, cancer and strokes, though. Those illnesses are linked to higher consumption of meat (Paleo-coronary, anyone?), dairy
Population studies show decreasing rates of heart disease and cancer with increased dairy and meat consumption. Look at post-war Europe and Japan.
I'm curious if you got these ideas from a certain organization that was started by a long-dead dentist? Your use of the phrase "assumed correlates like cholesterol" made me wonder. I guess you discount the Framingham study (or the few thousand follow-up studies that were published and peer-reviewed) that DO show a strong correlation between dietary cholesterol and heart disease?
I don't have time to post a few thousand citations that contradict your viewpoint right now, so I'll just start by mentioning the Cornell China Study:
The Cornell China Study is considered the most comprehensive study of health and nutrition ever conducted. It is a joint research program between Cornell, Oxford, and the Chinese Academy of Preventative Medicine. The data was from twenty plus years of research in 65 Chinese counties. It is often cited because of its size, scope, and the fact that there was such a wide range of diet data represented (high meat consumption populations on down to populations with little or no meat consumption, for example.) It found a strong correlation between increasing meat consumption and increasing disease and mortality. It is an interesting study. You should check it out.
American men eat a great deal more meat (10 to 20X in urban areas) than Chinese men, on average. American men also die of heart disease at almost 17 times the rate of Chinese men. This trend holds true, in the aggregate, no matter where or what time period you study. The countries with the highest meat and dairy consumption have the highest rates of cancer, diabetes and heart disease. Even in post-war Europe and Japan. Even accounting for genetic differences.
I don't want to come off as a TOTAL pompous ass, so I'll only cite more studies if you're actually interested or still want to argue with me. I spend between 15 and 20 hours researching nutrition each week, so it is a pet peeve of mine when I hear total BS passed off as truth. Like I said, proper nutrition is the best medicine on earth...even though eating properly is NOT necessarily simple, easy or fun. Wanting steaks and ice cream to be healthy does not make them so.
Other major flaws are readily found through google.
Elsewhere it comes to light that Colin Campbell has ties to animal rights activists, calling into question his motives.
I won't go out of my way to criticize the Weston A. Price Foundation, though. People can make up their own minds. I just find it funny that you question Campbell's motives, but not the motives of his critics.
Campbell has spent 50+ years as a scientist, largely funded by research grants from the National Institute of Health, and has arrived at the conclusion that diets low in animal products are healthier. Since a responsible nutrition researcher is likely to share and promote news that he believes to be both lifesaving and actionable, it is only natural that he would ally himself with other physicians that have also come to the same conclusion (Physician's Committee for Responsible Medicine) to spread that message. PCRM is a great organization, in my opinion, and their membership is composed of some of the leading physicians in the area of nutrition, including the physicians that are the only ones to have successfully reversed advanced heart disease without medication.
The Weston A. Price Foundation claims it is 'unbiased', in contrast to the PCRM. That is bullshit. Follow the money to smell the bias. The Weston A. Price Foundation's membership is largely composed of family farmers, including ranchers and dairy farmers. Do you think they might be a bit biased on the subject? You will notice that the foundation's homepage at http://www.westonaprice.org/ currently has logos from eight companies that sponsor their conferences. What do we see? A meat company, a seafood company, a supplement company, a publishing company, etc. Yep, no bias there.
By the way, the link you give is for a review of the book "The China Study" by Campbell and his son, which is not the ACTUAL published China research study I was citing. Only a chapter of that book is devoted to the China research study. Campbell wrote a rebuttal to the review you cite, which is reproduced at:
http://www.vegsource.com/articles2/campbell_china_response.h...
Masterjohn then wrote a rebuttal to that rebuttal...and then Campbell wrote a response to that. It's all very tiring, actually, because anyone can just look at the research studies in the aggregate and see who is right based on the science.
Sure, some of the suggestions are valid, but other assertions just aren't backed by science.
The problem is, this can get much more expensive. I'd love to be able to follow that for sustained periods of time. On the other hand, everything you eat that's not manufactured gives much more energy throughout the day. Who cares how much 'heat' a food generates in calories? What matters is what kind of energy you get from it.
Mellow people can be crazy too. Though, whether he's crazy or not, there isn't a shred of evidence presented besides the picture of "tribal health" he paints.
I've read many stories and know that avoiding cereals, grains, and milk is a good idea for weight loss and sugar management.
I was able to google some sources. Note that pesticides may also introduce toxins. I'm with Steve Pavlina on trying things and seeing if they work. The advice seems to be true.
http://www.nourishingourchildren.org/parents/cereal.html
Like he said in the article, he doesn't mean toxic in the unsafe sense. He means toxic in terms of, it's not good for your body. He means it's not the natural way every species on earth has consumed this food for thousands of years.
Where did she learn about these two studies? It doesn't say.
Let me tell you about an unpublished study where rats fed cornflakes were able to live for 100 years...
"In his book Fighting the Food Giants, Paul Stitt has tells us that the extrusion process used for these cereals destroys most of the nutrients in the grains."
(three paragraphs later, the rat study)
"Let me tell you about two studies which were not published. The first was described by Paul Stitt who wrote about an experiment conducted by a cereal company in which four sets of rats were given special diets... "
Since the book and study described by Paul are about cereal, and both paragraphs are near one another, I think the study is better described in that book. And since the study is attributed to a cereal company, that explains why it went unpublished.
raving: talking or behaving irrationally
"The problem is, this can get much more expensive."
No, the problem is there is no science here. Extraordinary claims demand extraordinary evidence. Claiming that all grains are toxic when uncooked is an extraordinary claim.
As I said, I have no doubt that many of these claims are true. I also have no doubt that some are false. The author gives me no basis for knowing which is which. I happen to be a bit of a nutrition and health nut (vegetarian for 14 years, vegan occasionally, avoid processed foods generally), but I'm also a believer in science. The often ill-informed assertions of some random dude on the Internet are not going to convince me to eat like a cave man.
It's like a microbiologist using the word "germs"
Is that actually true though? It seems like the sort of thing that should be easy to verify or disprove. Whether it's actually caused by diet would be harder to prove, but if these people really are free of all those health problems, that would be quite remarkable and should be studied more carefully.
I did find a couple peer-reviewed journal articles that seem to support the claim:
http://www.ajcn.org/cgi/reprint/71/3/665.pdf
http://www.ajcn.org/cgi/content/full/73/2/353
http://www.thepaleodiet.com/articles/Meat%20Paradox%20Final....
http://www.questia.com/googleScholar.qst;jsessionid=GqvJhxyH...
John Robbins is biased (toward vegetarianism/veganism), but his bias is based on sound principles (science, self-experience, environmental impact, ethics, etc.) The book is not preachy or anything, though. His other books are also really good. Especially if you're interested in the food industry, animal cruelty, nutrition and disease, etc.
He's a very interesting guy. He walked away from the Baskin-Robbins fortune to live a simpler and healthier life after his dad and uncle (Robbins and Baskin, respectively) both died of heart disease from eating too much of their own product. His one room, self-built cabin with second-hand furniture was featured on "Lifestyles of the Rich and Famous" and it became one of their most requested shows, to everyone's surprise. He's a pretty inspiring guy.
An overview of DeVany's health outlook is in the essay, <http://www.arthurdevany.com/webstuff/images/RevisedEssay.pdf.... Interestingly, in DeVany's view, endurance running (as in a marathon) is a very bad thing for long-term health.