The Nokia Patents and VP8 – Prior Art Hunting Time
groklaw.net
groklaw.net
From the links embedded in that it seemed like Nokia would not be open to being 'bought off' like MPEG-LA was, so this seems like it will end up being litigated which means a longer time with a cloud over the tech.
Back in the dot-boom days the mantra of Web 1.0 was "own the road" which was code for massive rent-seeking type businesses around locking up key pieces of the infrastructure and establishing control. Apparently that was a common way in the "real" (non computer) world of manipulating power (I've read accounts of companies/individuals buying up all the land that might have coal in it to put pressure on the steel mills who needed that coal etc).
I had some hopes that as we crossed 2015 and moved forward things would change radically (that is when the patents issued in 1995, the leading edge of the amazing patent race, start expiring). However watching the sorts of continuations and tweakish type things that have been going on is quite discouraging.
One bright spot was this story : http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20130124104536791 where Uniloc didn't even make it out of the gate. This in a courtroom that has been a favorite spot for patent trolls. So I take it as a small sign that the judiciary is developing better insights. Progress is slow, but I choose to see it as progress.
I think that is just legal posturing to get a higher rate for the patents. I doubt they would block it if offered,say, a couple of billion.
Empty threats? They have publicly listed the patents that they think are being infringed. That is more than the MPEG-LA ever did.
>If you have something against Google/VP8, sue them already.
It doesn't work like that. You need to show the judge that you exhausted all possible avenues before filing a case.
And you seem to think patent trials take no time. They take years. The fastest way for VP8 to be clear of this mess is if Google thinks the patents have some merit and they quickly come to a licensing agreement with Nokia like they did with MPEG-LA.
What I don't understand is why Google cares so much about VP8/x. What does Google get even if they "win"? It seems winning puts them in a worse situation as it just makes things like forking Chrome / Android easier.
I assume that, like many of their more audacious bets, the idea is to remove a pointless tax on innovation on the web and including the potential for interference in their business models going forward.
Just like Apple did back in 2002:
http://www.bizjournals.com/boston/blog/mass-high-tech/2002/0...
> Google wants a free, royalty-free codec.
But why? That is what I don't understand. The $5M/year in royalties is peanuts for Google. I suppose the 2015 deadline for web video is their issue, and they don't want to be in a bad negotiating position over YouTube.
Just to be clear, I personally want a royalty free codec, and think this type of software patent should be abolished.
Sorry for the G+ public link (should be viewable when not signed in), but I use it as my blog nowadays. https://plus.google.com/u/1/110412141990454266397/posts/QLuD...
Edit: ok, I'll just inline it here to save people the trouble
<QUOTE> What if any two devices, with just a few lines of JavaScript, could make a free voice call, or a free video call, anywhere, and not necessarily be subjected to control by phone carriers or other entrenched interests?
WebRTC, IMHO, is one of the most important technologies added to the web platform in the last couple of years. It is disruptive, perhaps too disruptive. It commoditizes things which used to be hard to do, even replicating something like Skype or Google Hangouts becomes much easier for small startups, and it scares big IHVs and ISVs who sell equipment and charge money for these services. It threatens to turn phone carriers into bit-pipes as well.
Putting on my tin-foil hat, it doesn't seem surprising to me that Microsoft (which owns Skype), Cisco (which owns WebEx), and Nokia (puppet of Microsoft), are pushing back and finding ways to delay it. The brouhaha over the VP8 codec is only one aspect, there are players who are worried their existing deployed VoIP/Video HW endpoints will be obsolete legacy equipment in the new WebRTC world, and so they do not want mandatory features which put them at a disadvantage.
But this technology is too important to be designed in a way that makes it hard to use, hitched to commercial legacy hardware, or encumbered by commercially controlled cartels like MPEG-LA.
</QUOTE>
However, in the software realm that just gives them a head start on the becoming trolls.
http://www.engadget.com/2013/03/25/nokia-attacks-google-over...
Nokia even sold off its headquarters lately to get some cash. It'd be a disservice to Nokia's shareholders if Nokia didn't try to extract some money for their IP from Google.
That's incredibly sad.
Gee, why doesn't Google give away for free their algorithm or Adwords secrets? Why should they, should be the question. Every company has an obligation to, with all other things considered, make as much cash as possible for their shareholders. Who cares that you think that everyone should bow to Google or Microsoft or ...?
No, this is not a real industrial strategy nor "maximizing value for shareholders"; on the face of it, this is just gratuitous trolling of a competitor. It's incredibly sad and really, really unclassy, hence my struggle to understand why they're doing this. However, plenty of people seem to think it's an acceptable move to "disrupt a competitor", so hey.
"Gee, why doesn't Google not sue people who created their own MapReduce (which Google has a number of patents on) implementations?"
Of course the problem with that is they don't sue others who use MapReduce, because while they aren't perfect, Google is pretty good about not abusing the legal system (unlike quite a few tech companies I could name).
Google is doing this because they see something in it for themselves, make no mistake. The true intention will show a few years down the line.