Ask HN: Berkeley or Urbana Champaign? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: Berkeley or Urbana Champaign?

3 pointskajecounterhack20 comments

I want to do web entrepreneurship. I want to be a hacker. Unfortunately, I applied and got into the Honors business track for U. Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. I also applied and got L&S for UC Berkeley. I'll be switching into computer science tracks ASAP, regardless of what school I go to, but a friend tells me it's easy to do at Berkeley and I'd lose 12k worth of scholarship if I switch at UIUC.

UIUC costs 17k because of my scholarships. Berkeley costs 50k and 40k are in loans.

My parents earn less than 100k annually (and a sister in college). Should I take the loans and go to Berkeley or stick with UIUC?

Complication: I met a girl named Jessica Mah and am interested in working with her, and this dilemma was actually caused by her talking me into thinking Berkeley would be more conducive for toward my efforts than I originally guessed. Originally, I was going to say, oh heck, I'll go to the cheaper school. But now I'm seriously weighing the pros and cons.

Anyone have some insight? I know most of you here are from the valley, anyway. Jess says many valley people either went to Berkeley, Stanford, or both. Not to mention she says she'll hook me up with people I'll want to meet...? ;)

Go to Berkeley. The weather is better. The town is cooler. It's close to the ocean. And the mountains. There are cuter asian girls (and better looking men.) The school itself is ranked higher... in every subject. It's the best public university in the country.

No matter what your major, it's a university everyone in the WORLD has heard of before. You are therefore considered smart for going there even if you major in Psychology. UIUC is only known in Illinois and some engineering circles.

Nobody goes to Berkeley and thinks "I should have gone to UIUC." But they do wonder the other way around.

(I went to university in the midwest and moved to Berkeley after I graduated, and then kicked myself for not even trying to go to Berkeley or Stanford.)

Is it worth the $40,000 debt x 4? $160,000...

Sure, I'd pay that much. YMMV. Also, if you establish residency you save about 15 grand a year.

UIUC is very famous in Computer Science. I don't think that people will give you a job because you are graduating from a FAMOUS university. It is more on what major you take than what university you are graduating from.

Think of this:

EE from Yale or EE from UIUC? I am sure that a EE company will definitely choose the latter.

Having a degree from a famous university may not automatically get you a job, but it will definitely get you more job interviews.

If you know for sure you're doing engineering and you got into the EECS program at UIUC, then it probably doesn't matter as much. However, it didn't sound like that was the case for the original poster.

It is not really hard to get a minor in CS in UIUC as long as you are good in Math and Science subjects.

But, one thing is sure: 17K vs 40k

Dude, I'm guessing you're only 18, so please take my advice: do not choose your college 'cos you're chasing some girl. By the time you graduate both you and she will be different people. And you're going to meet a ton of interesting people over the next 4 years (and I know you don't want to hear this right now, but so is she).

There is nothing wrong with UIUC, that's where NCSA is. Stick to your original plan. Heck, stay with the business program too and learn to hack on the side and maybe take some CS electives if you can get credit for them. Graduating with a ton of debt in what it looks like the economy's going to be ain't going to be pretty.

HAHA it's not like that, she's like one of the most well-connected 18 year olds on the west coast and I could be a part of a startup with her...

but thanks for the insight, exactly what my dad told me. ;_;

I am studying in UIUC now majoring in CS. It is a very good chance for you to transfer to CS major as long as you are doing good in all the science and math subjects when you are in college. Here, you will have the chance to study in the best building in the campus across NCSA - http://www.cs.uiuc.edu/about/siebelcenter.php ( I have 5 classes here every week even I am freshmen now)

Pros:

Startups? We have entrepreneurs like Jawed Karim(Youtube), Steve Chen(Youtube), Marc Andreessen(Netscape), Thomas Siebel, Max Levchin(Paypal), etc. (Geni, Yammer, Yelp, etc)

I am doing a startup right now with few of my friends. I am going to California this summer and I am putting my school on hold for next few semesters. One of my partner got into MIT before he came here. He decided to come to UIUC because the tuition fees in MIT was really too high (50K vs 13K). He thought that he made the correct decision after he worked on one of the project from MIT.

Cons:

The weather here sucks. It is really cold during the winter.

And, I am sure that Berkerley will have better "startup" environment. But, you will still see some startups around you in UIUC (My startup :X ).

(Anyway, I know Jessica Mah too. And, I can hook you up with people you want to meet too if you are coming to California this summer. But, do you think that networking really helps you to start your next big idea? Your skills are actually more important.)

> We have entrepreneurs like Jawed Karim(Youtube), Steve Chen(Youtube), Marc Andreessen(Netscape), Thomas Siebel, Max Levchin(Paypal), etc. (Geni, Yammer, Yelp, etc)

You _had_ them. All of them came out to the bay area to actually do their startups. That might tell you something :)

You are right. Bay Area is a good place to start a startup. But, he is going to study. Not starting a startup. What I wanted to say is: you don't necessarily have to graduate from a bay area university to start your startup.

Hmm can I do both?

It is really hard to start a startup if you are studying at the same time. That is why I have to put my school on hold for the next few semesters.

My overwhelming bias when I give advice on this subject of choosing colleges is to go as far away from home as possible, because that causes personal growth. (I didn't get that personal growth until AFTER college, when I lived overseas.) BUT, money does matter, and you are talking about a substantial money difference.

Now let's be clear: are you sure that you must take a financial hit to major in computer science at UIUC? Or can you major in business and still take quite a few CS courses anyway?

What is the assurance you can get into CS at Berkeley at all? I thought that was an "impacted" major there.

Good luck deciding. If the money were closer, it would be a no-brainer to go to Berkeley, but the money is not close, so there is much to be said for staying with Illinois.

Good point. My son majored in EE&CS at Berkeley. IIRC you cant transfer into CS from L&S. You might find yourself in the position that you go to Berkeley and cant get into CS. My info is 10 years old, so check it out.

Also Berkeley was very heavy into the Computer Engineering side of things. Be sure you like EE and hardware.

There's an alternative track at Berkeley for a CS major within L&S, if you're not admitted into the engineering school.

http://sis.berkeley.edu/catalog/gcc_view_req?p_dept_cd=COMSC...

In UIUC, it is really easy to minor in CS as long as you are interested in CS.

Do the math on how much it's going to cost you -- I would not want to get near 160k worth of debt, which is what it sounds like you're proposing. Also, you can take your summers, or even semesters to work in the bay area if you want. Hell for a few thousand dollars a year you can probably fly out there every weekend and work with your friends if you really wanted to.

Personally, I think anyone going over 50k of debt for an undergrad should really think it through, there may be cases where it makes sense but that is a lot of money. Also, having a significant debt load will limit your choices when you graduate from college -- the minimum salary that you'll need to live and pay your loans will be quite high.

Best of luck.

Most high school seniors think that college is about education. It is, just not the kind of education you think. College is about learning to be an adult, I got infinitely more experience and knowledge participating in campus groups and events than I ever did from class. You'll learn almost everything you need to know for your career on the job. So, I just can't see how Berkeley is worth the extra money.

Regardless of which school you go to, I highly highly recommend that you consider joining a fraternity. It is honestly one of the best decisions I've ever made in my life. There are certainly going to be houses that are full of douche bags, but if you find the right house (and there is one for everyone) you'll have an amazing experience. You'll learn so much about yourself and so much about dealing and interacting with people. And good interaction skills are a force multiplier, they'll make you a much more effective (and pay worthy) businessman/engineer/hacker.

At least go through Fall Rush, there is never an obligation to join and worst case scenario you've wasted a few hours, best case scenario you have 100 new friends for life.

I've never been to Illinois, but the Bay Area is pretty much guaranteed to have better weather and nicer outdoor type stuff, if that matters (it does to me, a lot).

Reply on news.ycombinator.com