The Impact of Dropping the SAT
insidehighered.com
insidehighered.com
Artificially increasing diversity is institutional racism which only serves to mitigate a symptom, not eliminate a cause. Rather than forcibly put more minorities through college, we should improve schools in poor and underprivileged neighborhoods.
Unfortunately, this real solution may take 10 to 20 years to see results... which is far shorter than the average term in public office.
I agree with this statement of policy. How do you think a college admission office ought to judge what an applicant's capabilities are?
The results will be tons of mediocre graduates unable to pay back their loans. That's OK... we'll pick up the tab; no fucking problem!
http://isteve.blogspot.com/2006/09/sacrificing-smart-black-k...
1) The SAT is measuring things other than academic ability/achievement, particularly non-academic cultural differences between a significant portion of the cited minorities and those having more success getting into SAT-mandatory institutions. This seems to be implicit in many calls for diversity.
2) The SAT IS a good measure of academic ability/achiement/admissibility, and statistically speaking, the cited minorities just aren't as likely to have the requsite levels of whatever academic oomph the test is measuring, presumably for environmental reasons.
http://www.wfu.edu/provost/rethinkingadmissions/conference_p...
--very little information about how much student characteristics would change along other dimensions besides ethnic diversity if the SAT were not considered at all as an admission factor.
It's easy; go look at those colleges that didn't consider the test, then compare the statistical outcomes predicted by the SAT for those who took it and what actually happened. (There may be some correlations to sniff out ("I know I'm only applying to non-SAT colleges so I won't take the test"), but I bet it's managable.)
Diversity's great and all (though when I say diversity, I mean real diversity and not a whole bunch of differently-colored people all believing the same thing, but that's a topic for a different discussion...), but it's evil to skew statistics to increase the number of "diverse" students taking out increasingly expensive loans who then do not end up with a degree just so you can feel good about how many happy rainbowed diversities your college has. If that is what is going on here. I admit I can't prove it but I don't like the smell.
(Yes, there are serious issues with educational opportunities that should be addressed, and I don't know what the solution is. I just know the solution isn't forcing the already-behind to take on tens of thousands of dollars of useless debt.)
The submitted article says there is exactly one such college, which I think from other sources I have read is correct. And the figures for that college are already posted to this thread.
After edit: Quite a few scholars contend that for a long time the student characteristic that has set college availability even more than SAT scores is family income. Laura D'Andrea Tyson, one of President Clinton's economics advisors, called for taking student family income more into account in admissions back in 2003:
http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/03_27/b3840045_...
Several studies and journalistic reports have shown that in previous years, student income limited college choices more than student test scores:
http://www.tcf.org/Publications/Education/carnrose.pdf
http://harvardmagazine.com/2005/05/a-thumb-on-the-scale.html
http://www.theatlantic.com/doc/200511/financial-aid-leveragi...
http://www.jkcf.org/assets/files/0000/0084/Achievement_Trap....
Now some colleges claim to have outreach to increase socioeconomic diversity on campus:
http://www.boston.com/news/education/higher/articles/2008/11...
Based on what I have heard in anecdotes about this year's admission results, Princeton, which was the first college in the Ivy League to announce a no-loan financial aid policy, is in earnest about admitting more students from low-income backgrounds.
The issue of the SATs still being a fantastic determinant of first year college success says something, but I'm not sure what. Perhaps the colleges would let in more minorities, but they'd not perform as well? Would those minorities do better since more of them would get in and they wouldn't be as isolated as they are now?
"These models suggest that any move away from the SAT or ACT in competitive colleges results in significant gains in ethnic and economic diversity. But the gains are greater for colleges that drop testing entirely, as opposed to just making it optional. (To date, only one institution -- Sarah Lawrence College -- has taken that step.)"
How does Sarah Lawrence College
http://collegesearch.collegeboard.com/search/CollegeDetail.j...
78% Women 22% Men
<1% American Indian/Alaskan Native 7% Asian/Pacific Islander 2% Black/Non-Hispanic 5% Hispanic 71% White/Non-Hispanic 4% Non-Resident Alien 10% Race/ethnicity unreported
37% in top 10th of graduating class 84% in top quarter of graduating class 98% in top half of graduating class
39% had h.s. GPA of 3.75 and higher 25% had h.s. GPA between 3.5 and 3.74 14% had h.s. GPA between 3.25 and 3.49 16% had h.s. GPA between 3.0 and 3.24 5% had h.s. GPA between 2.5 and 2.99 1% had h.s. GPA between 2.0 and 2.49
compare with Harvard
http://collegesearch.collegeboard.com/search/CollegeDetail.j...
51% Women 49% Men
1% American Indian/Alaskan Native 19% Asian/Pacific Islander 8% Black/Non-Hispanic 7% Hispanic 41% White/Non-Hispanic 10% Non-Resident Alien 15% Race/ethnicity unreported
95% in top 10th of graduating class 100% in top quarter of graduating class
or Princeton
http://collegesearch.collegeboard.com/search/CollegeDetail.j...
50% Women 50% Men
<1% American Indian/Alaskan Native 17% Asian/Pacific Islander 7% Black/Non-Hispanic 7% Hispanic 49% White/Non-Hispanic 11% Non-Resident Alien 8% Race/ethnicity unreported
97% in top 10th of graduating class 100% in top quarter of graduating class
or MIT
http://collegesearch.collegeboard.com/search/CollegeDetail.j...
46% Women 54% Men
1% American Indian/Alaskan Native 25% Asian/Pacific Islander 9% Black/Non-Hispanic 14% Hispanic 34% White/Non-Hispanic 9% Non-Resident Alien 7% Race/ethnicity unreported
97% in top 10th of graduating class 100% in top quarter of graduating class
in student diversity?