"I didn't downvote you, but that is not Economics 101. To give you an example, supply is irrelevant to price in a perfect monopoly."Yes it is. A perfect monopoly is very rare and i don't see any, you using an extreme case. Most importantly, the difference between company and industry disappears under conditions of a monopoly.
" A lot of the new startups that are rushing in are just noise."
That is your point of view and not a fact. This sets up my next point.
""Startups" are not a fungible product for which there are perfect substitutes.
True. Although there are many startups circling the same new hot space, after instagram, how many many new photo startups sprung up funded or not funded? SoloMo, how many startups circled this space when it was hot? I heard a VC say he is tired of hearing pitches about discovering friends nearby. Startups can be put into clusters, if you ran a k-means or hierarchical clustering algorithm on the startup scene you would see this. In these clusters is where VC's or angel investors are spoiled for choice, they may not have perfect substitutes but they are pretty darn close.
"exits from previous years means that there are a lot of angel investors out there flush with cash who are looking for the best deals."
This is just not true. Angel Investing is damn hard, have you ever looked at the return distribution of the VC industry, it is more fat-tailed than anything else. How many angel investors on AngelList have had profitable exits in the last 3yrs? I see a lot of people outside of tech with money coming in to be angel investors because its the new hot thing and they just need to put in $20 000 per company. I have seen places popup where they give you just accomodation and office space for a huge share of your business.
"From my experience (as an early employee at a VC-backed startup in SV), the top startups (95th percentile), are still seeing high seed valuations."
You are talking about extremes here again.
" If I recall correctly, pg stated somewhere a long time ago that he was fine with people downvoting just to express disagreement."
Yes, but wouldn't it make a better community if out of courtesy you did. I have seen people do it and i am impressed.