> But if you fast forward your changes on top of master and push that out as the new master, you lose all the benefits of branching. You could have as well made your changes on master, do pull --rebase once you've completed and then push out. That's how the history looks like.
Which benefits?
To me, the main benefits of branching happen as I'm developing a feature. I can work on something and quickly context-switch either back to master or to a different feature branch. For instance, if I'm working on a feature but a high-priority bug fix needs to be done first, I can switch back to master, check out a bug fix branch, and keep my feature work separate from it. When the bug fix is done, I merge it in and rebase my feature branch from it. The only thing I really care about historically is that features land in master all-at-once, which squashing, rebasing, and fast-forwarding does for you.
> Sure, if the rebase is clean, but conflicts are common.
You have to resolve conflicts either way though.
> Unless you use the github UI, in which case it will say 'Merge pull request ...'.
Still a recognizable pattern.
> Or you had to hotfix something on master - it happens.
That's called "not being disciplined about using feature branches". I suspect you run into this problem because you're suffering under a self-imposed constraint that branch names have to be globally unique and meaningful throughout your version history.
This isn't a problem unless you want to enforce a workflow where you always merge to master--the rebase/squash/ff workflow wouldn't actually pose a problem here, since all ancestor commits to master were deliberately put on master. My point is, if you follow an inconsistent workflow, no wonder your history is difficult to look through.