1) Flagging by people with karma over the threshold (currently set at 500).
2) For some domains, only 1/3rd of the upvotes count, e.g. Reddit, XKCD, images, tweets.
3) There is a "controversial" score which can bring down a story. Not sure how it is computed but perhaps it's based on number of comments versus number of points.
4) Voting ring detector. This can bring down a post pretty hard if it's triggered.
5) I suspect the HN supermoderators can cause a post to sink to the second page instantly.
Most of the time it's #1 that causes posts to go down.
I've usually seen it happen to posts that are anti-Apple, anti-Google or posts related to Microsoft that are not negative towards it. It's like the moderators flag posts that they don't want others to be seeing.
For example, the Surface Pro review