My job has destroyed the pleasure I get from programming

I've been at my current job for almost 2 years and I do a bit of everything. I've written an entire web application (ASP.NET+jQuery), written integrations as Windows services, written complex SQL queries for reporting, and maintained a 100+ table database. I hate all of it.

I'm tired of supporting it all. All I do anymore is boring reporting for boring business, or figuring out why a project's data is bad. I don't care anymore. I'm not impacting anything. Additionally, none of my management is from a programming background. I feel like in order to really learn I need to surround myself with people more talented than myself, which I don't feel like is the case at the moment.

I really want to find a new job but I'm terrified I'm going to leave and find out I'm totally burnt out from programming entirely, and hate my new job too. I'm not in a very startup-heavy area (Indianapolis) and I'm not in a position to move across the country. It's gotten to the point where I've considered dropping out of the industry entirely and finding something else entirely, but I know I'd like that even less.

What can I look for in a job that would, hopefully, revive the pleasure I used to get from programming?