That sounds distinctly like Anselm's ontological proof for the existence of God, and thus likely suffers from the same logical fallacies.
That sounds distinctly like Anselm's ontological proof for the existence of God, and thus likely suffers from the same logical fallacies.
That said, I do often feel that at the literal edges of our universe (in all the senses of that term), our uncertainties simply dominate everything and all of our guesses about the true nature of reality are dominated by that uncertainty. Something (or, depending, multiple somethings) must be true for some value of true, but I'm skeptical if we can discover it. If it popped up and simply flat-out told us what the truth was somehow (the Great Simulator writing the message in the stars [1]), we probably couldn't confirm it.
My favorite theory was that all the humans were passengers on a generational seed ship traveling to the next star, kept in near stasis to keep them alive and mostly sane during the millennial transit.
That would have played nicely with The Architect's explanation that in the perfect simulated world, humans went insane. So The Architect devised worlds with struggles. But the iteration we observed got out of hand, due to The Oracle's meddling.
Such a wasted opportunity.
Yeah, but there were a lot of explosions.
Pretty sure under our current understanding of physics, it's impossible to simulate a universe like our own within our own.
Impossible to perfectly model a universe, but not impossible to simulate something that looks like a tiny part of a universe.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ontological_argument
(no comment, just providing context)
The simulation argument says: if simulating minds is possible, and technologies eventually advance to the point that they can do it, a civilization would make lots of them. Thus, most minds are virtual, so your mind has a high base rate of being one.
Anselm's argument is: the best thing in the world would have to exist, since existence is better than non-existence. I define God as the best thing, so God must exist.
I don't quite see the parallel, but if you see something specific, I'd like to hear it.