Even documented and presented as a counter point in negotiation they simply denied the truth and quickly tried to pan the evidence.
Maybe I was naive, but it was so shockingly dishonest to me, I was mentally broadsided, mouth agape in disbelief. I mentally quit right then and there, and left as soon as possible.
Reminds me of designer friends of mine that constantly harp on about their 'design process'--but, do your users like your product in the end or not? That's the key. The process is merely a means to an end (there are many means in business, but generally one end: profit). If the end sucks, the means is worth very little (it's only worth is as a lesson in what not to do).
Here's how that negotiation would go with any hiring process I've ever worked with:
"So Mr. Pwnguinz, what are your salary requirements?"
"On this piece of paper I've written down the least I would work for. Now you please write down the most you are prepared to offer a perfect person, irrespective of whether I am that person or not. Then we shall exchange papers."
"This is highly irregular."
"If after exchanging papers, we find that your number is less than mine then we can save time."
Two ways I see this going:
A. "Thank you for your time Mr. Pwnguinz".
B. The hiring manager writes down what they were considering as an initial offer, you write down $0, and you become an HR office legend.