Much of personality decided at birth, say scientists
nzherald.co.nz
nzherald.co.nz
And it's not like you're Mister Spock, with one half of your personality fighting a completely different half. It's more like a smoothie, where you can't tell what part is the banana, what part is the strawberry, and so forth, except it tastes like a mixture of both. So really, what you're saying is a lot less coherent than it sounds.
To give an example, I think a large percentage of people would select an "easy going" kid if given the chance. But if we're honest with ourselves we find the people who have something to prove are the ones who make the major break throughs.
Bottom Line: Society's need for mal-adjusted people might be in conflict with a parents desire to have an affable child.
Would genetic modification be that different from the above example I gave?
Additionally, I have the right to reproduce. Who can tell me what I can or cannot do to produce my child?
Where as here there might be a rational reason for the Government to step in. So the very scary scenario that forms is one in which a parent's right to reproduce as they desire is pitted against a governments understandable need to keep society moving forward.
At least, that's what I'm afraid it might come to.
As soon as a country gives up on the concept of individual rights, it seems death follows.
Imagine if the news broke tomorrow about a better, smarter human baby being engineered. The result would be outrage, ferocious anger and prohibition.
Disease: an impairment of health or a condition of abnormal functioning
Is downs syndrome a disease? Is autism a disease? Is Asperger's a disease? Is a learning disability a disease? Is left handedness a disease? Is laziness a disease?
I think we can both agree that Downs Syndrome is a disease and that if were possible to fix via genetic manipulation we would. Other items i listed are obviously not so clear...
I make the point (again) that the health and state of my child is my responsibility and choice. If i want to choose to have my child be right handed, I should be given that choice.
I have always assumed that environment is a large factor in personality. What evidence is there in this data set to suggest that it isn't?
It strikes me as entirely plausible that they have the causal relationship reversed.
Yes I'm studying for a fourth year algorithms exam! :)
http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html
to see how many issues need to be checked as other researchers attempt to replicate this finding.
While this is undoubtedly a very interesting field, I found the article as written rather misguided. You need a brain scan to tell if your child is timid? Seriously? Oh and you would shout at your child, if only you hadn't been handed a scan at birth telling you your child's brain is such that it shouldn't be shouted at?
As for the advice about using this kind of information to affect how to raise a child, it runs contrary to all the best current child development advice. The child psychologists maintain that you should in every way avoid pigeonholing children (eg "she is the adventurous one", "he is the creative one"). If that is so, I can't imagine anything worse that "he is the one likely to get addicted to drugs".
This kind of thing is a small glimmer of understanding. Let's not rush to speculating about applications until we've thought about it a bit more, eh?
Personally, as a father, I think the more interesting application of data like this (if true, I tend to wonder about the order of causality as well) would be around how can I get my child out of their comfort zone. This is not shouting at my timid child, it is exposing the highly methodical child to free-form creative activities.
Also, coming from a family with a history of substance abuse problems, knowing that a child had a particular predisposition towards abuse would be useless without a solid way to do something about it. Otherwise, it just becomes yet another thing a parent needs to fear and become over protective about.
Yes, I mean it was reported well enough to see some of the holes in the study.
This study is clearly unamerican and probably racist.
Sorry about being so cynical but seriously that article's not exactly insightful. Was there ever an HN full of much better articles and never such as this one? Or it just my memory and wishful thinking fooling me into believing the old times were better? I bet that's genetic too.