Before MOOCs, ‘Colleges of the Air’
chronicle.com
chronicle.com
As with a MOOC, the videos were free to check out, although there was no text or problems provided alongside the lectures; but anyone could still check them out and watch them, or not, just as anyone can enroll in a MOOC, or not, at no cost in any case.
Which is why the article's point isn't really valid: all of these - MOOCs, video lectures in the library, and "University of the Air" alike - can't be compared to a traditional bricks-and-mortar university. Universities have entrance requirements and tuition charges; the people who attend courses are the ones who want to be there enough to pay high fees for the privilege, and whom the university admissions staff believe have the capacity to succeed in their studies. Quite a selection bias.
If MOOCs also end up having only 17% completion rates, it won't be all that surprising, but it won't mean that they're not a successful and valid innovation.
Oh no, not that again. Its the standard extrovert swipe at the introverts. It all boils down to I don't deserve credit for my in person American Prehistory to Civil War class because I never asked any stupid questions during the lectures and afterward I went home to my wife and kid instead of going out drinking afterwards. Such a tired, meaningless spacefiller of an argument.
There is little to indicate that "presence" in the modern form of the word when applied to undergraduate education at most schools could be equated with anything approaching a one-on-one experience. There are courses in this country with between 300-2500 students in attendance. What you're sitting for is essentially a performance.
The one area where I think we need to really fix online education (and in-person education as well) is to strengthen the connection between teaching fellows (or teaching assistants) and students. Graduate students are uniquely qualified for this role and if you supplanted an online education model with a combined cohort/mentor structure that pairs learners with course leaders, we could really have something that solves everyone's problems.
There is a glut of PhDs in this country in many disciplines. Making them a part of the online education model would make a difference in so many ways.
I like your idea because it resonates with my theory about peer pressure and my theory about lack of motivation both being undiscussed issues. Perhaps your interpretation is more correct than mine.
There have been a large number of popular press studies about the apparent failure of MOOCs from an interaction interpretation. I'd like to see at least one from a leadership perspective (the lecturer is the obvious leader in a physical class.. who's the leader online? Is there one? Can more than 5% of the population lead themselves?), maybe one from a peer pressure perspective, maybe one looking at ancient apprenticeships vs presentations we have now in brick -n- mortar vs watching videos online of the presentations. I don't need another interpretation of social interaction as a fail.
One interesting anecdote is way back when MOOC marketing was gaining traction, in the very first original AI class, a coworker and I both took the class and then dropped it. We socially interacted quite a bit, at least as much as I did back in physical school, but we both dropped it. I ended up reading the entire book, very good intro to AI book and worth my time so I can't blame either social interaction or the quality of materials in this anecdote. Dropout rates vs physical interaction with fellow students would be an interesting study. (edited to add my hypothesis would be minimal correlation between physical real world study groups and dropout rate)
The three arguments against were the discussed social interaction which was pushed pretty strongly, another claimed problem was credit was not available but when it was offered students wouldn't take for-credit classes (what does that mean, if anything?) and Blivens strange quote about minds needing to be built instead of stuffed.
Based on experience in classrooms, where the usual 90:10 ratio shows 10% of the students are 90% of the interaction, and even the most biased claims showing at least a quarter of the population is introverted, that would indicate the percentage of people who prioritize social interaction must be somewhere between the two fairly ridiculous extremes, lets say 90% to 25%. However actual success rates are staggeringly worse, like single digit may as well round down to zero. So as simple engineering guess, the cause of failure simply cannot exclusively be lack of interaction. If that were the case, a more realistic failure rate would be 50% or so because probably somewhere around half the population cares about that based on examination of extreme claims.
That leaves the article with little more than the usual "we all know the correct way for humans to live is to be extroverted, and clearly radio lectures / internet lectures are not an extroverts paradise, so lets marginalize the introverts and pat ourselves on the back for figuring that out to be the failure of MOOCs, how lame of them not to cater to our talkative desires as the masters". Eh, lame.
Whatever the distance education problem is eventually correctly identified, its not going to be social interaction. Look at another technology that's completely non-interactive yet tremendously popular... watching TV.
I suspect the true answer is likely to revolve around peer pressure and motivation. No one knows or cares if I drop a class or skip a video lecture, but if it went on my permanent facebook/google record, well, maybe I'd follow up... As for motivation I would agree that if possible to attend, sitting in class might be slightly better, and its so easy to attend class "somewhere" that anyone with the slightest spec of motivation is probably already sitting in a physical classroom leaving very few motivated people left for online classes. Not no one, just very few. Now those theories could have improved the article.
Of course, this remains an invalid claim for entirely different reasons, unless you interpret it as admitting that the "level" of sociability of MOOCs is often higher than a bricks-and-mortar class.
I recently completed an online master's program, offered by a traditional university, but in the MOOC format, with lectures in podcast format, and collaboration primarily via message boards, chat sessions similar to IRC, and email. There were conference calls as well, but the bulk of actual academic collaboration took place via text media. In-person meetings only occurred for one weekend in each semester.
As I perceived it, the depth and sophistication of interaction and collaboration among students was significantly higher here than in any bricks-and-mortar course I've ever taken. I attribute this to the asynchronicity of communication (it's pretty hard to get a large group of people together at the same time and all in the mental state conducive to productive discourse) and to the fact that people just communicate better in writing than in verbal speech (assuming they can write effectively, at least; if so, it's much easier to convey complex inter-related ideas in a paragraph or two of text than it is to attempt to verbalize them in real-time).
Quite like the comparing the experience of having a discussion on HN to discussing the same topic face-to-face with others, in fact.
OTOH, if "sociability" refers to merely recreational activity like grabbing a beer after a lecture, then yeah, bricks-and-mortar wins. But what's that got to do with school? If I want to socialize for the sake of socializing, I can go out for a beer with my local friends instead of my classmates.