If Management is the Only Way Up, We’re All F’d
moz.com
moz.com
During the review cycle, you were given, more or less, two ratings. A performance rating based on your current performance, and a rating based on the company's opinion of your ability to "rise through the ranks".
I liked what I did there. I did well at it (not just my opinion, but that of others and consistent performance reviews). I was comfortable with the job, the responsibilities, the pay and benefits, and the job provided a good challenge and no real risk of boredom or burnout. In short, I liked what I did and enjoyed the prospect of continuing to do that job.
That is career poison there. No matter how good you are in a position, and how much you enjoy it, your incentive is to keep moving up and if you're not so eager to do so, that's seen as a career limitation.
I was at the top end of the technical path I was in, and my next step up was to become management and manage employees who would be doing the job that I was doing now. MSFT saw that as a good career path, to take me away from a job I enjoyed, and put me in the position of curating other employees to do the job I enjoyed doing.
I understand a company's desire to make sure their employees are continually on a career path, but you can't move everybody up the ranks all the time. Sometimes the best employee you can have is one who's a good fit for a position and likes being in that position for a while.