This is the part that fucks the whole thing up. It's too vulnerable to misinterpretation or abuse.
This is the part that fucks the whole thing up. It's too vulnerable to misinterpretation or abuse.
It's also already a prosecutable offense to lock your company out of a business related account, so what is the point of establishing more legislation?
The reason for the legislation is that Illinois companies are specifically not permitted to demand credentials for personal social media accounts; it creates an exception to at-will employment in Illinois that would enable you to sue your employer if you were terminated incident to refusing credentials.
Only if you let HN and reddit rashly interpret your court decisions for you...
> It's also already a prosecutable offense to lock your company out of a business related account, so what is the point of establishing more legislation?
Because by itself, the previous language created an ambiguous situation. All the new bill does is clarify that the ban on asking for login credentials for a personal account doesn't override the offense of locking your company out of a business-related account.
No, I think it's pretty clear. Once information is publish via the company's twitter account, it becomes public information. It would be a very long stretch for retweeting public information to change the nature of a personal account to fall under this law.
Not to mention, Illinois' has notoriously labor friendly courts (I live in IL). While landing in court is an obvious problem for the employee to defend/prosecute, the reputation/record of IL labor courts make it an even steeper hill for an employeer to climb than for the employee.
While I would hope that most startups are above this kind of behavior, since startups tend to ask their people to use their personal accounts for marketing purposes, I have to at least have some concern...
In reality, anything that amounts of an exception to the at-will doctrine creates an enormous minefield for employers. Terminated employees are very frequently disgruntled and can be counted on, over time, in the large, to bring meritless cases. Employers who want to survive without being stuck up for settlements are going to become very process-bound for how they handle credentials.
Think of it this way: worst-case downside to employee from this law: early termination. Downside to employer: horrifically expensive legal debacle.
While Twitter is the obvious example, what about a Github account? I've patched bugs or merged pull requests for my employer's projects from my own account. Would that qualify?
Personal Github accounts are already a little bit fraught for that reason. The Illinois statute revision doesn't change the calculus; if you're an IL employee with a Github account you care about, you (a) don't want to be working for anyone who demands credentials to it, and (b) now have an avenue to extract a few tens of thousands of dollars from that employer should they ever be dumb enough to ask and then fire you.