The reasons are because:
- You're already committed to the name - you have a trademark and you say the name is a great fit for your startup
- You are already willing to pay $1000 for it ($500 more isn't that much in real terms especially, if you think you can at least recover $1500 for the domain if the startup fails)
- If your startup becomes successful, you are going to want to acquire that domain name (and once you're successful the owner will want a more substantial price)