I don't imagine any possible reason they'd have for removing the option that isn't creepy.
Though I agree it would be nice if someday we could enable temporary history and client-side encryption for everything. Perhaps this could be how DuckDuckGo grows beyond just search. I would look forward to such a future.
User expectations of privacy and magic are often in conflict, especially when sync is involved.
If they wanted to track you I imagine they'd be doing it anyway- that option is only to control whether the logs appear in your Gmail history.