Flat UI isn't some massive new UI paradigm? I thought that's exactly what it is.
> ... it's effectively a theme!
One of the major components of the success and pleasantness of iOS -- and Mac OS X before it -- has been platform consistency.
Apple has made a study of this, and that's part of what users are buying when they buy Apple's products. Dismantling that consistency (rather than, say, building on it) is detrimental to your user's experience and the cumulative value of both the user's purchase and training, as well as other developer's investment in furthering the platform.
There certainly can be a fine line between building on the platform standards and dismantling them, but rewriting all UI components is very much on the side of "dismantling".