Law student Anya Bargh was arrested for sending an email saying "Let’s celebrate diversity by having the next dean NOT be Jewish."
If that isn't protected speech I don't know what is.
http://www.volokh.com/2013/05/03/law-student-arrested-chiefl...
Law student Anya Bargh was arrested for sending an email saying "Let’s celebrate diversity by having the next dean NOT be Jewish."
If that isn't protected speech I don't know what is.
http://www.volokh.com/2013/05/03/law-student-arrested-chiefl...
That being said, it most likely is still protected free speech, as odious as those messages and postings were. I think the case will be dismissed, but her future in law school is probably over.
However, without having seen the arrest report or other documents, it seems from the news articles that the quote in my post is considered by the police to be in itself harassment.
Also, to be arrested for protected speech is bad enough, even if the charges are dismissed. Imagine if every time you held up a banner you could get arrested for harassement, it took a court case to acquit you.
If the police say "We are arresting person X because of this statement, and they also did some other stuff", then this suggests that the statements are part of the charges. But as I said above, it's hard to know for certain without seeing the actual charges.
The second is whether law enforcement might call something that should be protected speech harassment and I'm sure that they will and do from time to time. In this particular case I have no problem with calling it harassment if the other allegations are true.