With money from the states going down, do you continue to let in under qualified students from your own state? Or do you go private and run admissions as a true meritocracy, and make a few bucks in the process? What will the people of the state think when their "top 5% of her high school class" daughter gets a letter telling her to hit the bricks? Keep in mind, they don't know that the top 5% in an American high school is not the same thing as the top 5% in say . . . a secondary school in Singapore. Do Universities have an obligation to educate the people of the states they serve?
There is no denying that the current system is, in effect, affirmative action for white people. Supported by a level of public expenditure that is probably unsustainable long term. The question is, does everyone deserve a shot at a good education no matter how much money you have, or where you went to high school? If so, what is the best way to make that happen?
My own opinion was that the best thing for these states to do is to go private with their Universities and use them as immigration magnets. That way the state and its businesses benefit by having some of those students stay on after graduation. The University thrives, since, at least in Wisconsin's case, it would have the funds to support its teaching mission. And finally, the public expenditures being made to support these facilities are eliminated. You keep some level of affirmative action, and you expand the qualifications to include say 'people from the state we serve'. There is a quota, so not everyone who wants to would get in, but there would be some number of state residents in the student body. Added benefit, you really would get only the better students from that state since competition would be so fierce.
I realize that each University's situation is different. Even with that in mind I think that, at the University level, privatized education can work extremely well for the student, the University, local businesses, and the community.