I don't see why it has any material affect on someone requesting e-mail addresses: if it's valid, then it's valid.
This seems to be an example of the misplaced sense of propriety with which people approach validating e-mail addresses -- that somehow, your job isn't just to help the user enter an address, but also to define what is and is not 'reasonable'.
Imagine if companies refused to accept "1 Infinite Loop" as a street address because it's clearly ridiculous. Except that it's Apple's actual street address.