I found out about this after having three different people in a weeks time knock on my door and ask me where the fuse boxes are. Not a huge deal if my neighbors do it, but these are total strangers. At least when someone moves in to my building they have multiple background checks. And since full time residents live here they have a reason to be polite as they see me daily. They have some connection to the building and its residents.
A few weeks after the start of this I was woken up at three A.M. by my dog barking at the fire escape. There was someone on the fire escape looking into my bedroom window! After calling the police I found out that it was a renter from the unit below who wanted a better view and decided to peek into my unit at the same time. This has happened half a dozen times in the last year.
I work typical business hours. People who stay in the unit as guests are generally on vacation and this can lead to loud parties that last all hours of the night. I have a few neighbors who work strange hours and we work out noise agreements, you can't do that with people who are staying one or two days.
There's also the moral issue. It's hard to find a place in San Francisco, what they are doing is illegal, against the terms of their lease (it's very hard to evict tenants in San Francisco, the owners are trying), and they are denying someone a full time residence so they can make extra cash.
I like the idea of Airbnb but I agree that the people who rent units need to be held to some standards. A permit that neighbors can contest seems reasonable if it's going to affect their standard of living.
And of not suffering undue material harm during the process. Such as an extended lack of sleep adversely affecting one's employment.
There is also the possibility of escalating retaliation after you file a complaint.
There is the time and cost and confrontation of taking the other party to court, when that's what the law dictates and/or what police insist upon.
I'm significantly inclined to view AirBnB as a parasite upon the well being of long term, "real" tenants.
Both I and my extended group of friends and acquaintances have, en masse, had enough difficulty with neighbors -- before even adding AirBnB to the mix -- for me personally to give this viewpoint considerable weight.