Hacker News Reader

Hacker News

Comment by bdunbar | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

bdunbar

> The last time a modern military in a major conflict actually took and held ground was probably the Korean War.

Except for ..

Falkland Islands

Grenada

Desert Storm

OIF

View on HN

The Falklands are British. The British forces did not "take and hold ground", the repelled an invasion force.

Desert Storm: The US did not hold any ground for a long period of time. They defeated the Iraqi forces and withdrew.

Also, the population of the falklands is around 3000 total people. Even if it were an "occupation" (which I agree it is not since most people there identify as British), it would be like occupying a tiny village.

> The British forces did not "take and hold ground", the repelled an invasion force.

Incorrect. The Argentines surprised the small garrison, had the place in a few hours. The Brits then mobilized an amphibious force and had to take the Falklands back.

> did not hold any ground for a long period of time.

I don't recall there being a qualification for 'time spent on the ground'. And incorrect because we've had forces in Kuwait ever since.

You're arguing semantics. In the Falklands, the ground was British in the first place, and the Argentinians did not occupy the entire island; they repelled an invasion force, and saying that "held ground" is like saying the US has "held ground" from the British since the Revolution. Similarly, Kuwait was friendly territory; I was referring to Iraq.

> and the Argentinians did not occupy the entire island

One of us needs to review that conflict. And it's not me.

I'd definitely strike OIF from that list as it suffered from the same lack of ground control that OEF has and I'm not sure I'd count the Falklands or Grenada as a major military campaigns.

I specifically addressed Desert Storm (as the First Iraq War) as specifically a case where Western forces didn't hold territory. It was a hit, win and withdraw strategy and was over in what 100 hours? There was no ground held in the long term.

> There was no ground held in the long term.

We've had forces in Kuwait ever since Desert Storm ended.

The Soviet invasion of Afghanistan.

Grenada was a "major conflict"? Only if the entire US military versus a bunch of infighting leftists on a 344 square kilometer island with a population of less than 100,000 counts as a major conflict.

OP said 'take and hold ground'. Which is what Grenada was.

I will allow it was not a major conflict.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com